Suze Orman TwitterSuze Orman FacebookSuze Orman YouTubeSuze Orman LinkedIn
View Blog & News List

Attention Student Loan Borrowers: Can You Pass my Repayment Test?

November 24, 2014 at 1:01 AM

I fear many student loan borrowers are flunking out when it comes to choosing the right repayment plan.  Here’s a quick quiz to test your repayment smarts:

You have about $29,000 in federal student loans. That’s the average for borrowers who attended a private four-year non-profit school. You’re single and your adjusted gross income is $25,000.

What’s the best repayment plan?

A. The standard 10-year plan that will require monthly payments of nearly $300 a month. After 10 years the loan is completely paid off. You are done!

B. An income-based plan that can set your initial monthly payment below $20 and after 25 years of payments your remaining balance is forgiven-you are no longer on the hook for any remaining balance.

I bet you think B is the way to go.

Not so fast.

As enticing as it is to start with a low monthly payment, income-contingent repayment plans that forgive any remaining balance after a set period can end up costing you plenty.

For starters, interest payments over 25 years are going to cost you more than interest payments over a 10-year loan term. Using the same loan assumption from above, total interest payments over 10 years would be around $6,100. Under the Income-Based Repayment plan (IBR) interest payments would be more than $26,000 over the 25 years until the loan is forgiven. Add the principal payback and your total all-in repayment cost under the Standard 10-year plan is around $35,000. Even though the IBR starts you with a lower monthly payment the cumulative effect of payments and interest payments over 25 years ends up costing you more than $43,000.

But wait, it gets worse. Under current law, any remaining balance that is forgiven after 25 years will be treated as taxable income in the year it is forgiven. Yep, you will get a 1099-C tax form that notifies you that the unpaid balance was reported to the IRS, which in turn is going to expect you to pay income tax. Using the same example once again, the forgiven balance is more than $12,000. Even if your salary that year is low, adding $12,000 to your income could likely push you into a higher tax bracket. We don’t know what tax rates will be 25 years down the line, but even if I am generous and assume you’d somehow still be in a super low 10% bracket, that’s an extra $1,200 to settle with the IRS, bringing your total loan costs to nearly $45,000. Or about $10,000 more than what you’d owe under the 10-year repayment plan. (Recent borrowers with loans taken out after June 30, 2014 there’s a new repayment plan called Pay as You Earn (PAYE). Like IBR, if you qualify your initial payments are low. After 20 years or repayment the remaining balance is forgiven. But the same tax hit applies.)

I hope that opens your eyes to the true cost of opting for a long repayment schedule. I highly encourage you to play around with the government’s Student Loan Repayment Estimator. You can get customized estimates based on your actual outstanding loans, and the costs under different repayment plans based on your income, family size and where you live. (Eligibility for income-based plans is based on state-level income cutoffs. For the above example I assumed a single resident of Illinois with $25,000 in adjusted gross income.)

I totally understand how hard it may be to consider the higher payments that come with a 10-year repayment plan. But I want you to think long and hard if you can pull this off. Not only will you save a lot of money in the long run, you will have this debt completely paid off in 10 years. That’s a nice load off your finances and your conscience. Or you might consider working in a public service job that makes you eligible for the Public Service Loan Forgiveness Program. After 10 years of on-time payments your loan will be forgiven, and the IRS does not require you to pay tax on the forgiven balance.



Tag Cloud

couple financesMarlo Thomas!00% tuition paidcar buying mistakesThe Suze Orman Showlong-term care premiumspercentage men widowed 75-8420% down paymentreferrals Cory BookerStock Investmentsholiday spendingWall Streetphysical healthOne Wallet At A Timestudentcar leasingcommunity bankemergency fund multiple lenderspublic service career student loan repayment Credit Card Rate Increasecharges on credit cardtax refund fraudlong-term care successhome buying budgetInfluential Celebrityrent vs buyloved ones dependent on incomeGoodbyeunsubsidized Stafford loan3 savings buckets push yourself to save more for retirementHeartcalculate dependents annual income needsorigination fees19 years cash flow problemmonthly dental insurance premiumverify retirement plan with HR or plan sponsorno fee transferrefinancebuy home you can affordpremiumapproved medical 100% tax-freeno negativityrolloverlife insuranceRichwrite new goalPBS Specialhigh credit score discountraise your deductiblelower premiumhigh deductible health care plangrandchild summer job IRA contributionprotect your familybudgetprescription tierstretch out haircut appointments20% equityAmy Lacyetoverspend on giftschildren under 18open enrollment review not gender specific 20 year level term save moneydangerous money seasonfinancial goal phraseForeclosurepoint cost offset by savingsJose Rodriguezbalance transfer home buying seasonHow To Build Creditspeak new goalproperty taxfocus on needsdon't charge a pennymarriage inequalitysocial workMoney-Savingunexpected expenseanticipated salaryno interesthome budget after tax costNew York Lifeno life insurance financially irresponsibleSuze is my biggest mentorstudent loan repayment planbest interest ratesstore credit cardsCiti Simplicity Card not enough life insurancepaid in fulldebthigh premiumsUniversity of FloridaCOLAFinancial Cliffmax benefit coveredcredit cardbe true to yourselfreduce withholdinggift grandchild IRA contributionEasy Life Insurance small changes Communication Skills 10 year repayment plan loan is giftbe kind to yourselffraudulent returnlower rateLifestyleAccuQuote.comannual cost of living adjustmentexercise reguarlyis it kind?community collegeconsider roth 401(k)get over life insurance phobiareal estate mistakesStaffords this year have a fixed 6.8% interest ratehealthy aging 6 month waiting periodno private loanbuy homeaffordable premiumHSA tax savingsreplace permanent life insurance with termincentives for health care wellness screeningsecure creditlower overall drug costloan necessityFinancial Advicepermanent life insuranceconfidentdangerous retirement planHolidayInfluentialsFinancial Awareness Video FestivalescrowLong Term Care shoppinglower mortgage interestkids schedule payments2016 adjust withholding8 Rules20% down payment avoid feesleave a legacycompare monthly expensesmake saving a pleasurePhyllis Shelton expert long-term careAshley SpringerHDHP/HSAinsurance yearly reviewno retirement funds for down payment4 Must Have Documents Pay Off Debt Before Retirementstandard ratefamily save at least $100 monthlypreexisting condition not coveredExhibitionstrained relationshipEmergency Savingsage appropriate chorefinancial fearsfinancing car higher insurance deductibleMoneyteens and money401K8 month emergency fundRetirement Incomeautomatic paymentPersonal Financeincrease retirement contribution rate740 credit scorerising home priceslong term careletter to suzemaintain standard of livingdon't ignore open enrollmentincreased auto insurance premiumkid borrow firstdon't extend mortgage Post-Divorcestaycationsetup automatic savings withdrawcut monthly cellular bill401(k) ContributionsStudent Loanno late fee AARPSuze Orman ScholarshipSpendingpay credit debt ASAPSuze changed my lifetitle insuranceMost Influential Celebrities Listbreakdown projected monthly housing costcontribution mortgage brokerlearn good financial choicescut monthly cable billitemized deductionprotect loved ones waive home inspection bidBankno apologyincrease emergency savingsritual scheduleTelepicturesFundsdo you need life insurancefile taxes quicklyconfident of solutionface your financial fearNewtownsocial securityFinal Goodbyepay 100% cashone credit cardAARP Social security calculator2017 Taxesdeath benefit needs for familyburn outLong Term Care Insurance reduce monthly paymentlousy investmenthousing markethome buying mistakesNew american Dream big results know before you oweultimate compounding giftgraduationretirement accountsFinancialHoliday ShoppingHoliday SeasonSandy Hook PromiseFinancial Gift Cliffget health insurancepay more than minimumtake actionCivil Rightsback-to-school budgetcredit utilization rateget credit cardschool pay interest while in schoolfull retirement agethree year car loanHDHP'slowest cost fund optionYoung Adult focus on new truth overcome financial fearsLTC shoppinglong term goalprovider of financial supportFinancial Power of Attorneyloan no longer than 36monthscost of capitalization calculatorFinancial SystemMother2015 financial roadmapemployer offered life insurancemonthly benefit tax ID theftSandy Hook Elementary Schoolemergency fund savingsprotect dependent dental discount planFHA loan feesbad retirement planningwomen long term careSuze Orman's Money Warspay high rate off firstteach importance of helping othersBaby Boomers50 over 50advice for college graduatesmax employer matched 401(k) contributiongrandparent IRA contribution HDHP no waiting periodpaying for collegeonly offered while employed best loan deal powerfulmanage student loansdon't buy wantstaxes3% debt transferred savings pleasureinsurance mistakehealthy youis it true? car loanno sneaking in feescompare provider pricingBill and PennyFinancial Awarenessfile asapadult childrenzero rate transfer dealshome ownershipresponsible with moneyat worst still pay 75% benefitinsuranceSave Us MoneyFinancial EducatorRetirement Savingspercentage of women widowed 75-84loan big picture college graduateGay CouplesForbesAlarm Clockbuy down University of IllinoisMass MutualConventional loan PMIvalue moneycommitverify wellness screening and programsteach your child good money habitshome insuranceSchool of Social WorkEric Dodge highest possible benefitdeath benefit 20 to 25 times annual incomedon't derail retirement savingshealthy retirement weightchildren's bookavoid burn outis it necessary?paid vacationworst financial mistakeLTCi ASAPrepay student loansmental healthwomen longer life spansecured cardCollege of Veterinary Medicineheartachedoctor no longer in networkcnbc alarm clockpay off debtsame sex marriage band end Floridapeace of mindSelectQuote.comsame-sex marriageidentity fraudidentity theftpay down student loan debtStudent Debt CrisisCredit scoreallowance taskshop online guaranteed level term policydental savings plan2016 adjust estimated taxmarriage financial responsibilityalternative FICO scoreretirementForbes Top 10Commencementspring summer savingsdoctors in networkone annual feesocial security not going brokederailed planlow credit scoreCNBCdear suze8 month safety netstudent loan debtlife insurance name trust as beneficiaryonly refinance if it payslow mileage discountunder 18 financial giftraise deductiblesMoney Market15-year refinance dealmeet monthly student loan repayment estimatornear historic lowsTeachstandard deduction CPI-Wcontribute household expenses allowanceiffy incomeAmericans don't use all paid vacation timegift up to 14,000Adequate Auto and Home Insuranceemployer funding HSAHDHP's are not badnew cardon't defer interest paymentsdepreciating asset Veterinary Schoolfinancial argumentsget the most out of social security enjoy saving US Tax CodeLTCSuze approvedLovefour steps to retirement savings retain separate credit cardsco-sign Federal Funds Rate3 bucket approachcreate new truthswitch to roth 401(k)gay marriage ban end Florida Prime Rate Increaseterm life insurancemobile apppositiveemotional stakesFiscal Responsibilitysummer job match income would you decline a bonuscan you afford itschedule vacationIRA contribution gifted moneySuze Orman spouse Kathy Travisfederal student loan deferment quick closingGiftsbuying a carautomatic withdraw to savings Roth 401(k)Prime Rate Rise 2015debit cardplanjanuary billsdebt freeearn allowancegift not loanWarner Bros Television Grouptraditional vs roth 401(k)dream schoolmax employee matchinterest on student loansrefundno tax on withdrawlsfinancial independencecostly insurance mistakehigh down paymenthealthy retirement blood pressure10% donate to charityoverspend on nights outcollege studentadd teenBeautywives should be involved in retirementFinancial Solutions For YouLong Term Care premiumsEmployer Matched ContributionStudent Debtpresident Obamais it necessaryHDHP's are good for youMortgage Credit Availability Indexdental insurance Auto Savings teensFRAdon't cover cosmetic dentistryinterest capitalizationBankruptcy3 step financial road mapretirement planChanging Livescomparison shoppingshort term goal Urbana-Champaignkeep a schedulesocial security never insolventsidelined40% toward financial goallet them have 50% controlhome related tax break bonus don't use allowance as bribeworkaholicdon't do five year car loanSatisfyingsave pay down car loandon't spend mortgagepurely financial standpointhigh FICO scoreno splurge require chore in exchange for allowancecredit reportrequired disclosureOverspendingswitch to spouse coverageETF'sfinancial concernFICO Scoreautomate student loan paymentsDurable Power of Attorney for Health CareFICO at least 720be good examplealways use all paid time offbecome member initial tax break women outlive menterm insurance20 to 25 times annual incomejuggle multiple financial goalsmortgage disclosureclosing disclosurebetter loan ratesclosing fees2015 record year car salesvalentines daystay positiveSuze Ormanretirment savingsbill paying prioritiescredit unionwomen live longerlive below your meansmoney vowsyours, mine & ourslow down paymentGracedo not pay allowance for good behaviorstudent loan repaymentFree Debt Eliminatorborrow each year, capitalization is going to pile up Revocable Living TrustFICO credit score credit card mortgageadjust allocations special saving accountbuying car 2016television hostCredit Card Interest Rateback door Roth IRAincrease retirement savingsraise insurance deductibleage appropriate goalspublic service loan forgiveness programWashingtonGiftmoney-aware childInvest for savings growthuniversal college accessignore 6 month grace period negotiate points with bank or sellerroth irabetter termsGay Rightsreal estate marketlow-cost index mutual fundclosing costs 2% of loanInterestreduce interest ratemortgage interest tax deductionresponsiblebetter loan dealsborrowing plan bad decisionsprotect and provide for minor child home loan credit score below 740 overspend on dining outcredit managementdon't blow tax refund

View Blog & News List
People First. Then Money. Then Things.
Connect with me on Facebook Connect with me on YouTube Connect with me on Twitter
© 2017 Suze Orman Media Inc. All rights reserved.
 |  Search  |  Sitemap  |  Privacy  |  Terms
Sign Up For E-mail Offers
Open Panel
Close Panel