Suze Orman TwitterSuze Orman FacebookSuze Orman YouTubeSuze Orman LinkedIn
View Blog & News List

Attention Student Loan Borrowers: Can You Pass my Repayment Test?

November 24, 2014 at 1:01 AM

I fear many student loan borrowers are flunking out when it comes to choosing the right repayment plan.  Here’s a quick quiz to test your repayment smarts:

You have about $29,000 in federal student loans. That’s the average for borrowers who attended a private four-year non-profit school. You’re single and your adjusted gross income is $25,000.

What’s the best repayment plan?

A. The standard 10-year plan that will require monthly payments of nearly $300 a month. After 10 years the loan is completely paid off. You are done!

B. An income-based plan that can set your initial monthly payment below $20 and after 25 years of payments your remaining balance is forgiven-you are no longer on the hook for any remaining balance.

I bet you think B is the way to go.

Not so fast.

As enticing as it is to start with a low monthly payment, income-contingent repayment plans that forgive any remaining balance after a set period can end up costing you plenty.

For starters, interest payments over 25 years are going to cost you more than interest payments over a 10-year loan term. Using the same loan assumption from above, total interest payments over 10 years would be around $6,100. Under the Income-Based Repayment plan (IBR) interest payments would be more than $26,000 over the 25 years until the loan is forgiven. Add the principal payback and your total all-in repayment cost under the Standard 10-year plan is around $35,000. Even though the IBR starts you with a lower monthly payment the cumulative effect of payments and interest payments over 25 years ends up costing you more than $43,000.

But wait, it gets worse. Under current law, any remaining balance that is forgiven after 25 years will be treated as taxable income in the year it is forgiven. Yep, you will get a 1099-C tax form that notifies you that the unpaid balance was reported to the IRS, which in turn is going to expect you to pay income tax. Using the same example once again, the forgiven balance is more than $12,000. Even if your salary that year is low, adding $12,000 to your income could likely push you into a higher tax bracket. We don’t know what tax rates will be 25 years down the line, but even if I am generous and assume you’d somehow still be in a super low 10% bracket, that’s an extra $1,200 to settle with the IRS, bringing your total loan costs to nearly $45,000. Or about $10,000 more than what you’d owe under the 10-year repayment plan. (Recent borrowers with loans taken out after June 30, 2014 there’s a new repayment plan called Pay as You Earn (PAYE). Like IBR, if you qualify your initial payments are low. After 20 years or repayment the remaining balance is forgiven. But the same tax hit applies.)

I hope that opens your eyes to the true cost of opting for a long repayment schedule. I highly encourage you to play around with the government’s Student Loan Repayment Estimator. You can get customized estimates based on your actual outstanding loans, and the costs under different repayment plans based on your income, family size and where you live. (Eligibility for income-based plans is based on state-level income cutoffs. For the above example I assumed a single resident of Illinois with $25,000 in adjusted gross income.)

I totally understand how hard it may be to consider the higher payments that come with a 10-year repayment plan. But I want you to think long and hard if you can pull this off. Not only will you save a lot of money in the long run, you will have this debt completely paid off in 10 years. That’s a nice load off your finances and your conscience. Or you might consider working in a public service job that makes you eligible for the Public Service Loan Forgiveness Program. After 10 years of on-time payments your loan will be forgiven, and the IRS does not require you to pay tax on the forgiven balance.



Tag Cloud

car loanWarner Bros Television Groupwomen long term careBankunder 18 financial giftlive below your meansConventional loan PMIbreakdown projected monthly housing costemergency fund savingsnew cardo you need life insurancebuying a carlower mortgage interesttitle insuranceget the most out of social security mortgage disclosureage appropriate choreFiscal Responsibilityprotect dependent long term careretirement accounts4 Must Have Documents big results financial independenceInterestloan big picture Overspendingcnbc alarm clockget health insuranceSuze is my biggest mentorBaby Boomerscontribution Civil Rightscreate new truthis it necessary401(k) ContributionsretirementHolidayheartacheclosing costs 2% of loanNew american Dream paid vacationlowest cost fund optionemployer funding HSAmoney vowsbuy homehome buying mistakesemotional stakes3 bucket approachbuying car 2016same sex marriage band end Floridastudent loan repayment planLTCFree Debt Eliminatorrolloverwould you decline a bonusbalance transfer AARPETF'sUrbana-Champaignhome loan credit score below 740 Gay CouplesRichhome budget after tax costletter to suzeSuze Ormanquick closingTelepicturesjuggle multiple financial goalsinterest capitalizationbest interest ratesanticipated salaryhealthy aging file taxes quicklyMortgage Credit Availability Indexback-to-school budgetstandard rateCory Bookerloan necessityallowance taskno negativityvalue moneypay 100% cash2016 adjust estimated taxlong-term care premiums!00% tuition paiddon't buy wantshighest possible benefitlower premiumcompare monthly expenses8 month emergency funddon't ignore open enrollmentinitial tax break real estate mistakesderailed plansocial security not going brokedon't defer interest paymentsPrime Rate Increasebe true to yourselfverify retirement plan with HR or plan sponsorsetup automatic savings withdrawGiftsretirement planfocus on new truth retirment savingsmortgageFederal Funds Rateconsider roth 401(k)dangerous money seasonSandy Hook Elementary Schoolavoid burn outoverspend on giftspay down student loan debtspeak new goalhealthy retirement weightpaying for collegeAshley Springerat worst still pay 75% benefitAdequate Auto and Home Insurancefour steps to retirement savings Mass MutualStudent Debtunsubsidized Stafford loansavings pleasureAuto Savings tax ID theftannual cost of living adjustmentoverspend on nights outHDHP 2017 Taxestraditional vs roth 401(k)refunddon't do five year car loanCollege of Veterinary Medicineprotect loved ones real estate market8 month safety netno private loanclosing disclosuremobile appUniversity of FloridaRetirement Savingspercentage men widowed 75-84Employer Matched ContributionCOLAterm insuranceWall Streetdear suzewomen live longerBill and Pennymax benefit coveredsocial securityno tax on withdrawlsorigination feeshome ownership3 savings buckets negotiate points with bank or sellerFundsemployer offered life insurancecredit reportrefinanceEmergency SavingsFICO credit score credit card mortgageUS Tax Codefocus on needsdental insurance GraceInfluentialsschool closing feesrequired disclosureFinancial Cliff2016 adjust withholdinglong term goalno life insurance financially irresponsibleRevocable Living Trusthigh deductible health care planallowancebetter termssavingswaive home inspection bidHoliday Shoppingcar leasingreduce monthly paymentdeath benefit 20 to 25 times annual incomepowerfulpay down car loanonly refinance if it paysloved ones dependent on incomeco-sign don't charge a pennybuy home you can affordescrowstudenthome buying budgetstandard deduction reduce interest rateAmy Lacyet10 year repayment plan mortgage interest tax deductiondeath benefit needs for familypurely financial standpointcalculate dependents annual income needsbetter loan dealspay more than minimum6 month waiting perioddoctor no longer in networkrent vs buyno interestadvice for college graduatescomparison shoppingdon't extend mortgage shop online guaranteed level term policyHow To Build Creditdon't use allowance as bribeemergency fund 3 step financial road mapbetter loan ratesThe Suze Orman Showwomen longer life spanfinancial argumentsmarriage inequalitymarriage financial responsibilitymake saving a pleasureis it kind?file asapdental discount plangrandchild summer job IRA contributionsmall changes confident of solution8 Rulesone annual feegrandparent IRA contribution Roth 401(k)learn good financial choicesloan no longer than 36monthsFinancial Advicepay interest while in schoolYoung Adult NewtownEric Dodge costly insurance mistakebill paying priorities20% down payment avoid feescut monthly cable bill20% down paymentPrime Rate Rise 2015Marlo Thomasis it necessary?alternative FICO score20 year level term HDHP/HSAloan is giftmonthly dental insurance premiumFinancial Systemstretch out haircut appointmentsno retirement funds for down paymentSatisfyingone credit carddo not pay allowance for good behaviorLoveresponsible with moneyholiday spendinginsurance yearly reviewLong Term Care premiumsexercise reguarlySave Us Moneyis it true? only offered while employed universal college accessFinancial Solutions For YouFinancial Gift Cliffprovider of financial supporttelevision hostgift not loancut monthly cellular billFinancialFICO at least 720switch to roth 401(k)Citi Simplicity Card enjoy saving 3% debt transferred CNBCrepay student loansMoney-SavingSpending19 years cash flow problemdebtVeterinary Schoolunexpected expenseincentives for health care wellness screeningCredit scoreignore 6 month grace period HSA tax savingsdream schooldon't derail retirement savingshome insuranceGay Rightsadult childrenkid borrow firstvalentines daymanage student loansconfidentwives should be involved in retirementbudgetdoctors in networkSuze Orman spouse Kathy Travislow-cost index mutual fundFinancial Power of Attorneylow credit scoremoney-aware childsave Teachget over life insurance phobiateens and moneymental healthForbesForbes Top 10Staffords this year have a fixed 6.8% interest ratesecure creditmeet monthly fraudulent returnborrowing plan student loan repayment estimatorfinancial concernretain separate credit cardshome related tax break bonus graduationswitch to spouse coveragefull retirement age50 over 50increase retirement savingssuccess15-year refinance dealadjust allocations can you afford itproperty taxno splurge increase emergency savingssidelinedchildren under 182015 financial roadmaphigh FICO scoreoverspend on dining outMotherbe kind to yourselflower rateautomate student loan paymentsdebt freefinancing car point cost offset by savingsno fee transferInvest for savings growthstudent loan debtmonthly benefit gay marriage ban end Florida planthree year car loanrising home priceszero rate transfer dealssocial workGoodbyeFRAPay Off Debt Before Retirementshort term goal couple financesopen enrollment review age appropriate goalschildren's bookCommunication Skills AccuQuote.comprotect and provide for minor child don't blow tax refundno late fee Money Marketraise deductiblesStudent Loanno sneaking in feesmax employer matched 401(k) contributionCPI-Wterm life insuranceNew York Lifetake actionStudent Debt Crisisroth iracost of capitalization calculatorHDHP's are not badinterest on student loansleave a legacydon't spend write new goalInfluential Celebrityraise insurance deductiblesame-sex marriagenot gender specific BeautySchool of Social WorkHeartLong Term Care shoppinglousy investmentapproved medical 100% tax-freehigher insurance deductibleSuze approvedLong Term Care Insurance iffy incomeGiftSuze changed my lifeface your financial fearPBS SpecialChanging Livesbe good examplepublic service loan forgiveness programAARP Social security calculator40% toward financial goalcontribute household expenses Financial Educatordon't cover cosmetic dentistrylow down paymentovercome financial fearsrequire chore in exchange for allowancemultiple lenderspay credit debt ASAPFinal Goodbye401Ksecured cardsummer job match income Washingtoncollege studentincrease retirement contribution ratestore credit cardsSandy Hook Promiseitemized deductionultimate compounding giftbad retirement planningknow before you owecollege graduatekeep a schedulebuy down protect your familyyours, mine & oursmaintain standard of livinggift grandchild IRA contributionhigh premiumsfinancial goal phraselower overall drug costPost-DivorceFHA loan feeslife insurancepublic service career student loan repayment best loan deal responsiblestay positive2015 record year car salesprescription tierbad decisionsIRA contribution gifted moneyreduce withholdingLifestyleno waiting periodnot enough life insuranceearn allowancebecome member preexisting condition not coveredautomatic withdraw to savings percentage of women widowed 75-84BankruptcyFinancial AwarenessFICO Scorespecial saving accountinsurancestudent loan repaymentAmericans don't use all paid vacation timeteach importance of helping othersfamily save at least $100 monthlypermanent life insuranceHoliday SeasonRetirement Incomedental savings planmax employee matchcredit managementStock Investmentspaid in fulltaxescharges on credit cardalways use all paid time offOne Wallet At A Timeborrow each year, capitalization is going to pile up community bankteach your child good money habitsfederal student loan deferment push yourself to save more for retirementlong-term care commitLTC shoppingPhyllis Shelton expert long-term careSelectQuote.comUniversity of Illinoisdangerous retirement plangift up to 14,000community collegecar buying mistakesreferrals kids schedule paymentsget credit cardpositivereplace permanent life insurance with termworst financial mistakesocial security never insolventcredit cardpresident ObamaDurable Power of Attorney for Health Caresave moneyautomatic paymentSuze Orman's Money Warspremiumphysical healthPersonal FinanceEasy Life Insurance let them have 50% controlfinancial fearsExhibition20% equityinsurance mistakeCredit Card Interest Ratetax refund fraudCommencementpay off debtHDHP'sdepreciating asset life insurance name trust as beneficiarywomen outlive menAlarm ClockMoneySuze Orman Scholarshiphealthy retirement blood pressure10% donate to charityadd teenjanuary billsFinancial Awareness Video Festivalcredit unionJose Rodriguezidentity theftMost Influential Celebrities ListForeclosuremortgage brokerback door Roth IRApay high rate off firstCredit Card Rate IncreaseLTCi ASAPdebit cardnear historic lowsverify wellness screening and programsritual scheduleHDHP's are good for youteensidentity fraudhousing market

View Blog & News List
People First. Then Money. Then Things.
Connect with me on Facebook Connect with me on YouTube Connect with me on Twitter
© 2017 Suze Orman Media Inc. All rights reserved.
 |  Search  |  Sitemap  |  Privacy  |  Terms
Sign Up For E-mail Offers
Open Panel
Close Panel