Suze Orman TwitterSuze Orman FacebookSuze Orman YouTubeSuze Orman LinkedIn
View Blog & News List

Attention Student Loan Borrowers: Can You Pass my Repayment Test?

November 24, 2014 at 1:01 AM

I fear many student loan borrowers are flunking out when it comes to choosing the right repayment plan.  Here’s a quick quiz to test your repayment smarts:

You have about $29,000 in federal student loans. That’s the average for borrowers who attended a private four-year non-profit school. You’re single and your adjusted gross income is $25,000.

What’s the best repayment plan?

A. The standard 10-year plan that will require monthly payments of nearly $300 a month. After 10 years the loan is completely paid off. You are done!

B. An income-based plan that can set your initial monthly payment below $20 and after 25 years of payments your remaining balance is forgiven-you are no longer on the hook for any remaining balance.

I bet you think B is the way to go.

Not so fast.

As enticing as it is to start with a low monthly payment, income-contingent repayment plans that forgive any remaining balance after a set period can end up costing you plenty.

For starters, interest payments over 25 years are going to cost you more than interest payments over a 10-year loan term. Using the same loan assumption from above, total interest payments over 10 years would be around $6,100. Under the Income-Based Repayment plan (IBR) interest payments would be more than $26,000 over the 25 years until the loan is forgiven. Add the principal payback and your total all-in repayment cost under the Standard 10-year plan is around $35,000. Even though the IBR starts you with a lower monthly payment the cumulative effect of payments and interest payments over 25 years ends up costing you more than $43,000.

But wait, it gets worse. Under current law, any remaining balance that is forgiven after 25 years will be treated as taxable income in the year it is forgiven. Yep, you will get a 1099-C tax form that notifies you that the unpaid balance was reported to the IRS, which in turn is going to expect you to pay income tax. Using the same example once again, the forgiven balance is more than $12,000. Even if your salary that year is low, adding $12,000 to your income could likely push you into a higher tax bracket. We don’t know what tax rates will be 25 years down the line, but even if I am generous and assume you’d somehow still be in a super low 10% bracket, that’s an extra $1,200 to settle with the IRS, bringing your total loan costs to nearly $45,000. Or about $10,000 more than what you’d owe under the 10-year repayment plan. (Recent borrowers with loans taken out after June 30, 2014 there’s a new repayment plan called Pay as You Earn (PAYE). Like IBR, if you qualify your initial payments are low. After 20 years or repayment the remaining balance is forgiven. But the same tax hit applies.)

I hope that opens your eyes to the true cost of opting for a long repayment schedule. I highly encourage you to play around with the government’s Student Loan Repayment Estimator. You can get customized estimates based on your actual outstanding loans, and the costs under different repayment plans based on your income, family size and where you live. (Eligibility for income-based plans is based on state-level income cutoffs. For the above example I assumed a single resident of Illinois with $25,000 in adjusted gross income.)

I totally understand how hard it may be to consider the higher payments that come with a 10-year repayment plan. But I want you to think long and hard if you can pull this off. Not only will you save a lot of money in the long run, you will have this debt completely paid off in 10 years. That’s a nice load off your finances and your conscience. Or you might consider working in a public service job that makes you eligible for the Public Service Loan Forgiveness Program. After 10 years of on-time payments your loan will be forgiven, and the IRS does not require you to pay tax on the forgiven balance.



Tag Cloud

no waiting periodorigination feeshigh premiumsGiftsadvice for college graduatesface your financial fearinitial tax break 30 year mortgage write new goal3% debt transferred doctor no longer in networkemotional stakesdream schoolcostly insurance mistake20% down payment avoid feesstudent loan repayment plandon't extend mortgage Financial SystemFederal PLUS loansave moneydon't cover cosmetic dentistryGoodbyeHoliday Seasonbad retirement planningLong Term Care Insurance home related tax break bonus itemized deductionclosing feescost of capitalization calculatorkid borrow firstpay down car loanETF'scharges on credit carddon't do five year car loanARM8 Rulesmarriage financial responsibilityback-to-school budgetMotherapproved medical 100% tax-freedo not pay allowance for good behaviorspecial saving accountplanat worst still pay 75% benefitStaffords this year have a fixed 6.8% interest rateget over life insurance phobiadon't derail retirement savingsLong Term Care shoppingalternative FICO scorepublic service career student loan repayment grandparent IRA contribution ForbesaffordabilitySuze changed my lifeCredit Card Rate Increaseenjoy saving Financial Awareness Video Festivalsavings pleasureHDHP/HSAdoctors in networkignore 6 month grace period Alarm Clocktax ID theftAuto Savings wives should be involved in retirementdebtincreased auto insurance premiumback door Roth IRArequired disclosuregrandchild summer job IRA contributionwaive home inspection bidsmall changes short term goal children's bookreduce withholdingidentity theftWarner Bros Television Groupsummer job match income kids schedule payments20 year level term don't ignore open enrollmentjanuary billsno fee transferholiday spendingprescription tierhome budget after tax costchildren under 18gift up to 14,000low mileage discountloan big picture Beautypay off debtprotect loved ones monthly benefit real estate marketteensloved ones dependent on incomeMost Influential Celebrities ListInterestdangerous retirement planAmericans don't use all paid vacation timeCOLACory Bookershop online guaranteed level term policyFinancial Solutions For Younon conventional routeHDHP's are good for youOverspendingoverspend on giftscnbc alarm clockloan is giftFiscal Responsibilitydepreciating asset 401Kheartacheinterest capitalization2017 Taxesborrowing plan overcome financial fearsmax benefit coveredget the most out of social security credit unionnew carpermanent life insurancefinancial concernDeath Benefitinsurance mistakedental discount planno private loans50 over 50keep a schedulesuitablebad decisionscollege studentemergency fund home insurancecontribute household expenses Federal Reserveoverspend on nights outfour steps to retirement savings co-sign Lifestylealways use all paid time offcredit cardpay more than minimumopen enrollment review cut monthly cable billHDHP juggle multiple financial goalsMortgage Credit Availability Indexbetter loan deals3 savings buckets healthy youretirementlow credit scoreEasy Life Insurance social securitybuy homeFHA loan feesrequire chore in exchange for allowanceRetirement Incomesidelinedsecure credithealthy retirement blood pressureMinor Children buy home you can affordfocus on needscalculate dependents annual income needsbetter termsCollege of Veterinary Medicineworkaholicroth irabill paying prioritiescredit utilization rateSandy Hook Promisefinancial aidraise insurance deductibleTelepicturesgift not loanteens and moneyescrowfinancial fearsNewtownInfluential CelebrityHigh Credit Scoreschool Gay Rightslower mortgage interestmultiple lendershealthy aging successallowance tasktax refund fraudbest interest ratesresponsible with moneyFree Debt Eliminatorretirement plandon't defer interest paymentsBaby BoomersMarlo Thomascompare provider pricingpaid in fulldebt freeaccelerate dental workhome buying budgetrent vs buyage appropriate goalsswitch to spouse coveragepoint cost offset by savingsFRAAshley SpringerpositivecommitEric Dodge marriage inequality6 month waiting periodtake actionincrease emergency savingsgraduation2016 adjust withholdingMust Have Documents10% donate to charitypaying for collegeBankpaid vacationmax employer matched 401(k) contributionFixed Rate MortgagePhyllis Shelton expert long-term caretoo expensive schoolcan you afford itnear historic lowsoverspend on dining outswitch to roth 401(k)death benefit 20 to 25 times annual incomeno splurge mortgageidentity fraudborrow each year, capitalization is going to pile up compare monthly expensesWall Streetraise your deductibleterm insurance8 month emergency fundNew american Dream University of Illinoisfinancing car Bill and Penny!00% tuition paidPBS SpecialMoney-SavingSatisfyingLTCi ASAPlong term careRevocable TrustStudent Debt Crisisraising mortgage rates 3 step financial road mapritual schedulewomen longer life spando you need life insurancemoney vowsterm life insuranceHeartloan necessitynot gender specific protect and provide for minor child SpendingLovefocus on new truth three year car loanphysical healthcouple financesno sneaking in feesSandy Hook Elementary Schoolhighest possible benefitultimate compounding giftChanging Liveshigher monthly paymentForbes Top 10best interest of investorfamily save at least $100 monthlycommissionslousy investmentdeath benefit needs for familyPay Off Debt Before Retirementconfident of solutionFICO at least 720spring summer meet monthly ARM Cautionverify retirement plan with HR or plan sponsorHSA tax savingsvalentines dayLTCcar leasingreal estate mistakesbudgetEmployer Matched Contributionstandard rateUS Tax Code2015 financial roadmapverify wellness screening and programsstudent loan repayment estimatordebit cardworst financial mistakeFinal GoodbyeSchool of Social Workfinancial argumentsCD'sFinancial Gift Cliffshorter payback periodlow down paymentrepay student loansNew York Lifestandard deduction Moneyreplace permanent life insurance with termincrease retirement contribution rateVital Documentslong-term care Selfishcredit reportlowest cost fund option10 year repayment plan consider roth 401(k)19 years cash flow problemstudent loan repaymentlower overall drug costonly offered while employed Roth 401(k)traditional vs roth 401(k)staycationcar loancreate new truthreduce interest rateEmergency SavingsInvest for savings growthAmy Lacyetraise deductiblesunsubsidized Stafford loanbecome member Gifthome ownershippay interest while in schoolmake saving a pleasureincrease retirement savingsconfidentsavingsannual cost of living adjustmentmental healthzero rate transfer dealsfederal student loan deferment home buying mistakesrising home priceslong-term care premiumsRetirement Savingsadjust allocations 20% down paymentpush yourself to save more for retirementRevocable Living Trusthealthy teeth3 bucket approachnegotiate points with bank or sellerMoney Marketstudentis it necessary?don't blow tax refundhigh deductible health care planbuying car 2016AccuQuote.comno apologyVeterinary SchoolFinancial Power of Attorneypeace of mindinsurance yearly reviewlower rateInflation Benefitsocial workStock InvestmentsGay CouplesCommunication Skills housing marketSwap Older Annuities or Life Insurance purely financial standpointPrime Rate Increase20% equityis it kind?know before you owemobile appWillpublic service loan forgiveness programproperty taxdon't use allowance as bribesocial security not going broke401(k) Contributionsbuying a caris it true? Civil Rightscommunity collegelong term goalno life insurance financially irresponsibleLTC shoppingbetter loan rateslow-cost index mutual fundinterest on student loansrolloverFinancial AwarenessCombo Insurance ProductsMass Mutualprotect your familyhealthy retirement weightpay down student loan debtemployer funding HSAgift grandchild IRA contributionUniversity of Floridatitle insurancehigh credit score discountemployer offered life insurancesecured cardhigh FICO scoreHigh FICO Score = Better Ratecut monthly cellular billfile taxes quicklyadult childrencredit managementhigher insurance deductibledon't spend would you decline a bonusSuze Orman Scholarshipno tax on withdrawls4 Must Have Documents get health insuranceexercise reguarly2016 adjust estimated taxmonthly dental insurance premiumSuze approvedlife insurance name trust as beneficiarypresident Obamabuy down premiumburn outdental savings planfinancial goal phrasehome buying seasonDurable Power of Attorney for Health Careanticipated salaryincentives for health care wellness screeningwomen outlive mennot enough life insuranceno negativity8 month safety netsame-sex marriagelower premiumbe kind to yourselfiffy incomeno interestTeachprovider of financial supportloan no longer than 36monthsFinancial Cliffbe true to yourselfCredit scoreFinancial Educatoruniversal college accessgay marriage ban end Florida powerfulCiti Simplicity Card raising interest ratesAdequate Auto and Home Insurancemortgage interest tax deductionbig results eliminate credit card debtwomen live longerFICO credit score credit card mortgageyours, mine & oursrefundteach your child good money habitsspeak new goalbe good exampleavoid burn outpreexisting condition not coveredSelectQuote.comretirement accountsCredit Card Interest Ratepercentage men widowed 75-8420 to 25 times annual incomeBankruptcyLong Term Care premiumsquick closingearn allowancewomen long term careadd teendon't buy wantsUrbana-Champaign40% toward financial goalderailed planbreakdown projected monthly housing costbalance transfer store credit cardsRichHoliday ShoppingStudent Loancostly legal financial independenceCNBCAARP Social security calculatorcomparison shoppingpercentage of women widowed 75-84Suze is my biggest mentorfull retirement ageautomatic paymentlearn good financial choices2015 record year car salesinsurancelet them have 50% controlFinancial Advicedental insurance Student DebtSuze Orman spouse Kathy TravisJose Rodriguezstretch out haircut appointmentsno late fee Suze Orman's Money Warshome loan credit score below 740 student loan debtHDHP's are not badFundsmortgage disclosureprofessional advisorsame sex marriage band end Floridastrained relationshippay high rate off firstPersonal FinanceOne Wallet At A Timeretain separate credit cardsis it necessaryunder 18 financial giftreferrals taxesmax employee match15 year mortgageGraceautomate student loan paymentsearn more on savingsFederal Funds Rateone annual feesocial security never insolventFICO Scorecollege graduateage appropriate choredear suzeHDHP'spay credit debt ASAPbest loan deal engaged in financesmoney-aware childfiduciarylife insurancereduce monthly paymentfraudulent returncontribution dangerous money seasonschedule vacationSuze Ormanresponsibleno retirement funds for down paymentCommencementmaintain standard of livingExhibitionWashingtondon't charge a pennyConventional loan PMIHow To Build Creditletter to suzeaffordable premiumonly refinance if it pays15-year refinance dealcar buying mistakesPost-Divorceretirment savingshigh down paymentclosing costs 2% of loancommunity bankvalue moneypay 100% cashallowancelive below your meansstay positivemortgage brokerAARPIRA contribution gifted moneyleave a legacyFederal Stafford loanLegal Guardianprotect dependent Influentialshealthy gumsone credit cardSave Us Moneyautomatic withdraw to savings The Suze Orman Showno private loanHolidayfile asapsave Foreclosureclosing disclosurerefinancesetup automatic savings withdrawYoung Adult 740 credit scoreteach importance of helping othersget credit cardPrime Rate Rise 2015unexpected expenseeight month living expense television hostFinanciallower interest ratemanage student loansCPI-Wemergency fund savings

View Blog & News List
People First. Then Money. Then Things.
Connect with me on Facebook Connect with me on YouTube Connect with me on Twitter
© 2017 Suze Orman Media Inc. All rights reserved.
 |  Search  |  Sitemap  |  Privacy  |  Terms
Sign Up For E-mail Offers
Open Panel
Close Panel