Suze Orman TwitterSuze Orman FacebookSuze Orman YouTubeSuze Orman LinkedIn
View Blog & News List

Attention Student Loan Borrowers: Can You Pass my Repayment Test?

November 24, 2014 at 1:01 AM

I fear many student loan borrowers are flunking out when it comes to choosing the right repayment plan.  Here’s a quick quiz to test your repayment smarts:

You have about $29,000 in federal student loans. That’s the average for borrowers who attended a private four-year non-profit school. You’re single and your adjusted gross income is $25,000.

What’s the best repayment plan?

A. The standard 10-year plan that will require monthly payments of nearly $300 a month. After 10 years the loan is completely paid off. You are done!

B. An income-based plan that can set your initial monthly payment below $20 and after 25 years of payments your remaining balance is forgiven-you are no longer on the hook for any remaining balance.

I bet you think B is the way to go.

Not so fast.

As enticing as it is to start with a low monthly payment, income-contingent repayment plans that forgive any remaining balance after a set period can end up costing you plenty.

For starters, interest payments over 25 years are going to cost you more than interest payments over a 10-year loan term. Using the same loan assumption from above, total interest payments over 10 years would be around $6,100. Under the Income-Based Repayment plan (IBR) interest payments would be more than $26,000 over the 25 years until the loan is forgiven. Add the principal payback and your total all-in repayment cost under the Standard 10-year plan is around $35,000. Even though the IBR starts you with a lower monthly payment the cumulative effect of payments and interest payments over 25 years ends up costing you more than $43,000.

But wait, it gets worse. Under current law, any remaining balance that is forgiven after 25 years will be treated as taxable income in the year it is forgiven. Yep, you will get a 1099-C tax form that notifies you that the unpaid balance was reported to the IRS, which in turn is going to expect you to pay income tax. Using the same example once again, the forgiven balance is more than $12,000. Even if your salary that year is low, adding $12,000 to your income could likely push you into a higher tax bracket. We don’t know what tax rates will be 25 years down the line, but even if I am generous and assume you’d somehow still be in a super low 10% bracket, that’s an extra $1,200 to settle with the IRS, bringing your total loan costs to nearly $45,000. Or about $10,000 more than what you’d owe under the 10-year repayment plan. (Recent borrowers with loans taken out after June 30, 2014 there’s a new repayment plan called Pay as You Earn (PAYE). Like IBR, if you qualify your initial payments are low. After 20 years or repayment the remaining balance is forgiven. But the same tax hit applies.)

I hope that opens your eyes to the true cost of opting for a long repayment schedule. I highly encourage you to play around with the government’s Student Loan Repayment Estimator. You can get customized estimates based on your actual outstanding loans, and the costs under different repayment plans based on your income, family size and where you live. (Eligibility for income-based plans is based on state-level income cutoffs. For the above example I assumed a single resident of Illinois with $25,000 in adjusted gross income.)

I totally understand how hard it may be to consider the higher payments that come with a 10-year repayment plan. But I want you to think long and hard if you can pull this off. Not only will you save a lot of money in the long run, you will have this debt completely paid off in 10 years. That’s a nice load off your finances and your conscience. Or you might consider working in a public service job that makes you eligible for the Public Service Loan Forgiveness Program. After 10 years of on-time payments your loan will be forgiven, and the IRS does not require you to pay tax on the forgiven balance.



Tag Cloud

closing feesEmergency Savingsbuying car 201620 year level term marriage inequalitypercentage men widowed 75-84dear suzenew carroth iraretirment savingsgraduationinterest on student loansmonthly benefit Revocable Living Trust401KsuccessPrime Rate Rise 2015take actioncontribution contribute household expenses don't cover cosmetic dentistryloan no longer than 36monthsFinancial AwarenessLegal Guardiandon't defer interest paymentsretirementstay positivepositiveget health insuranceRetirement Savingsdoctors in networkcreate new truthHDHP'smeet monthly cut monthly cable billinterest capitalizationcar loanHDHP raise deductiblesbalance transfer paying for collegeFinancial Solutions For Youpay interest while in schoolCNBCfinancial independenceemployer offered life insurancetitle insuranceoverspend on nights outonly offered while employed bill paying prioritiesapproved medical 100% tax-freespeak new goalpay down car loandental savings plancredit reportget credit cardRichrequire chore in exchange for allowance20% down payment avoid feesinitial tax break dangerous retirement planno negativitycar buying mistakesFundsbecome member High Credit Scorenot enough life insurancefull retirement ageunsubsidized Stafford loanWarner Bros Television GroupYoung Adult Motheridentity theftUS Tax Codethree year car loanpresident Obamagrandchild summer job IRA contributionmake saving a pleasureverify retirement plan with HR or plan sponsorGiftface your financial fearfile taxes quicklyHoliday SeasonSpendingclosing disclosurefamily save at least $100 monthly15-year refinance dealverify wellness screening and programsSelfish20 to 25 times annual incomeannual cost of living adjustmentAmy LacyetStudent Debtdangerous money seasonincreased auto insurance premiumvalue moneyteach importance of helping otherscut monthly cellular billhigh premiumsworst financial mistakeprotect loved ones max employer matched 401(k) contributionBeauty20% equityhealthy youFinancial Power of Attorneyone annual feepublic service loan forgiveness programshorter payback periodonly refinance if it paysfour steps to retirement savings lower mortgage interestco-sign money vowsalternative FICO scoreMarlo Thomasgift up to 14,000Vital Documentsgift grandchild IRA contributionheartachewomen longer life spanpercentage of women widowed 75-84New York LifeMoneyautomate student loan paymentsincentives for health care wellness screeningBill and Pennyresponsible with moneydon't buy wants10% donate to charityage appropriate goalsGay Rightsbuy down Lifestyledeath benefit needs for familyno tax on withdrawlsanticipated salaryBankis it true? universal college accessfinancial aidgay marriage ban end Florida 8 Ruleshealthy retirement blood pressureMoney Marketcompare provider pricinghome buying mistakesUniversity of Illinoishome buying budgetearn allowanceemergency fund student loan repayment planRetirement Incomesame-sex marriage30 year mortgage switch to spouse coveragefinancial fearscan you afford itemotional stakespay credit debt ASAPretirement plan10 year repayment plan Federal Funds Rate3 bucket approachTelepicturesstudentno sneaking in feessavingstax ID theftkids schedule paymentshigh credit score discountMortgage Credit Availability Indexconsider roth 401(k)women outlive menHigh FICO Score = Better Ratelearn good financial choicesitemized deductionSatisfyingInvest for savings growthescrowpay down student loan debtNewtowntraditional vs roth 401(k)AARPForbesfinancing car standard ratecompare monthly expensesFederal Stafford loanAdequate Auto and Home Insurancehigh FICO scorebe kind to yourselfSuze Orman ScholarshipStock InvestmentsFiscal Responsibilitycnbc alarm clockpurely financial standpoint2015 record year car salesSuze approvedidentity fraudlong-term care pay high rate off firstmanage student loanspowerfulAARP Social security calculatorhighest possible benefittaxesburn outreal estate mistakesSandy Hook Elementary Schoolno waiting periodunexpected expensecomparison shoppingmortgage interest tax deductionARMMoney-Saving4 Must Have Documents do you need life insurancesave replace permanent life insurance with termholiday spendingCredit Card Rate Increasegift not loanAuto Savings employer funding HSAbad decisionsbe true to yourselfhome loan credit score below 740 Credit scorecost of capitalization calculatorhousing marketLong Term Care Insurance loved ones dependent on incomeadult childrenFICO ScorePhyllis Shelton expert long-term carehealthy retirement weightsummer job match income home insurancepreexisting condition not coveredAccuQuote.comloan necessityrolloverdream schoolno private loansLTCwomen long term careincrease retirement savingspaid vacationrefinancepay off debtbest interest ratesclosing costs 2% of loanknow before you oweplanreduce interest rateno private loanvalentines daycredit unionraise your deductibleretirement accountsinsurance yearly reviewSandy Hook Promisebe good examplemultiple lenderstelevision hostmortgage disclosurefocus on needsallowanceCredit Card Interest Ratestrained relationshipBaby Boomers6 month waiting periodnot gender specific GraceJose Rodriguezno splurge zero rate transfer dealsDurable Power of Attorney for Health Carelong-term care premiumsHSA tax savingsMinor Children eight month living expense add teenstandard deduction adjust allocations waive home inspection bidGay Couplesdental discount planone credit cardStaffords this year have a fixed 6.8% interest ratenear historic lowslife insurance name trust as beneficiaryrent vs buywrite new goalSuze is my biggest mentorinsurancekid borrow firstVeterinary School20% down payment15 year mortgagebudgetRevocable Trust2016 adjust estimated taxteens and moneynon conventional routedental insurance social security not going brokesidelinedcommunity collegepaid in fullconfident of solutionprotect and provide for minor child Final Goodbyeopen enrollment review Commencementalways use all paid time offPost-Divorce3 step financial road mapwomen live longeremergency fund savingsAmericans don't use all paid vacation timedoctor no longer in networkbad retirement planningCiti Simplicity Card save moneyphysical healthdo not pay allowance for good behaviorbetter loan dealssocial workHDHP's are not badlow-cost index mutual fundTeachcommitcouple financespoint cost offset by savingscollege studentHolidayInfluential Celebrityreduce monthly paymentprotect dependent yours, mine & oursdebt freePersonal Financemax employee matchborrow each year, capitalization is going to pile up automatic paymentlow mileage discountbuy home you can affordstudent loan repaymentSave Us Moneyterm life insuranceunder 18 financial gift2017 Taxesritual scheduleConventional loan PMIIRA contribution gifted moneyultimate compounding gift3 savings buckets confidentARM Cautionletter to suzedeath benefit 20 to 25 times annual incomeMost Influential Celebrities Listprescription tierpeace of mindChanging Livesfinancial concern740 credit scorehome budget after tax costExhibitionInfluentialslive below your meansPBS SpecialGiftsWashingtonretain separate credit cardsallowance taskprotect your familyFICO at least 720Forbes Top 10public service career student loan repayment premiumavoid burn outadvice for college graduatesFinancial Systemlow down paymentSuze changed my life2015 financial roadmapraise insurance deductiblecar leasinglong term goalStudent Debt CrisisNew american Dream Cory BookermortgageInterestcollege graduateno retirement funds for down paymenthigher insurance deductiblerepay student loansresponsibleFinancial AdviceHeartincrease retirement contribution rateWillfocus on new truth mortgage brokercommunity bankenjoy saving grandparent IRA contribution maintain standard of livingschedule vacationAshley SpringerGoodbyecredit managementLong Term Care premiumsPay Off Debt Before Retirementcalculate dependents annual income needslong term careUrbana-Champaigncredit card!00% tuition paidFinancial Educatorsocial security never insolventdon't extend mortgage lower overall drug costpay more than minimumbetter loan ratesmonthly dental insurance premiumaffordable premiumhome ownershipFinancialLovebest loan deal Federal PLUS loanwives should be involved in retirementloan is giftschool high down paymentfederal student loan deferment no interestleave a legacyno late fee CPI-W40% toward financial goalnegotiate points with bank or sellerFinancial Awareness Video Festivalcostly legal Student LoanCollege of Veterinary MedicineteensEmployer Matched Contributionmarriage financial responsibilitybetter termsCivil Rightsjanuary billsoverspend on dining outfile asapEasy Life Insurance 2016 adjust withholdingsavings pleasuredon't blow tax refundETF'sterm insurancebuy homelower premiummobile app401(k) ContributionsFHA loan feesmental healthlousy investmentOne Wallet At A Timerequired disclosureThe Suze Orman Showautomatic withdraw to savings is it kind?get over life insurance phobiadon't derail retirement savingsreduce withholdingMust Have Documentsdon't use allowance as bribeexercise reguarlyno fee transferbuying a carworkaholicCommunication Skills don't spend lower interest raterefundchildren under 18secured cardSchool of Social WorkSuze OrmanUniversity of Floridalower ratedebtfinancial argumentsFICO credit score credit card mortgagesame sex marriage band end Floridaborrowing plan too expensive schoolreal estate marketlowest cost fund optionsocial securityHoliday Shoppingiffy incomeLTC shoppingquick closingSuze Orman spouse Kathy TravisHDHP's are good for youaffordabilitylife insuranceForeclosureLTCi ASAPmax benefit covereddon't ignore open enrollmentstaycationbig results let them have 50% controldepreciating asset home buying seasonCOLAloan big picture spring summer provider of financial supportshort term goal Financial Cliffis it necessary?Mass Mutualcredit utilization rateSelectQuote.comkeep a scheduletax refund fraudwould you decline a bonusstudent loan debt3% debt transferred no life insurance financially irresponsibleFinancial Gift Cliffmoney-aware childFree Debt Eliminatorteach your child good money habitsstudent loan repayment estimatorchildren's bookincrease emergency savingsno apologyhome related tax break bonus switch to roth 401(k)overcome financial fears8 month safety netfraudulent returncostly insurance mistakeinsurance mistakehigher monthly paymentEric Dodge breakdown projected monthly housing costget the most out of social security Fixed Rate Mortgagereferrals Long Term Care shoppingback-to-school budgetorigination feesshop online guaranteed level term policypermanent life insuranceignore 6 month grace period back door Roth IRAdebit carddon't do five year car loanoverspend on giftsFRArising home pricesBankruptcyHDHP/HSAstretch out haircut appointmentslow credit scoreAlarm Clock19 years cash flow problemat worst still pay 75% benefitderailed planSuze Orman's Money Warsstore credit cardsjuggle multiple financial goalscharges on credit cardpay 100% cashHow To Build Creditdon't charge a pennysetup automatic savings withdrawpush yourself to save more for retirementPrime Rate Increasesecure credit50 over 50high deductible health care planis it necessaryWall Streetage appropriate chorefinancial goal phrasehealthy aging Roth 401(k)small changes 8 month emergency fundOverspendingspecial saving accountproperty tax

View Blog & News List
People First. Then Money. Then Things.
Connect with me on Facebook Connect with me on YouTube Connect with me on Twitter
© 2017 Suze Orman Media Inc. All rights reserved.
 |  Search  |  Sitemap  |  Privacy  |  Terms
Sign Up For E-mail Offers
Open Panel
Close Panel