Suze Orman TwitterSuze Orman FacebookSuze Orman YouTubeSuze Orman LinkedIn
View Blog & News List

Why You Should Seriously Consider a Roth 401(k)

July 09, 2015 at 12:00 AM

You know I love, love, love Roth IRAs. One of the prime reasons being that in retirement you will not owe a penny of tax on your withdrawals. That’s quite different from a Traditional IRA where every penny will be taxed at your ordinary income tax rate.

It wasn’t until nearly 10 years ago that 401(k) plans were allowed to offer a Roth version. Today about half of plans currently give employees the option of saving in a Traditional 401(k) or a Roth 401(k). Yet very few employees are opting for the Roth 401(k).

I think that can be a shortsighted mistake.

Yes, it’s absolutely true that there is an upfront tax break when you save in a Traditional 401(k) that you don’t get with a Roth 401(k). Every dollar you contribute to a Traditional account reduces your taxable income for that year. But money you put into a Roth account is made with after-tax dollars, so there is no “upfront” tax break.

I get that the tax break right now can be appealing. But what you need to carefully consider is the long-term impact-or tradeoff-of that decision. As I mentioned, all money withdrawn from a Traditional 401(k) will be taxed at your ordinary income tax rate, while there will be no tax on withdrawals from a Roth 401(k).

I think the prospect of no taxes in retirement on your retirement withdrawals is well worth considering. One of the common rules of thumb is to go with the Roth only if you expect your tax rate in retirement to be lower than your tax rate today. I’ve got two issues with that.

First, who knows where tax rates will be 10, 20, 30 years from now? I have to tell you that today’s rates are a lot lower than when I started my financial planning career.

Second, even though your income will likely be less in retirement, that doesn’t mean you automatically will be in a much lower tax bracket, if your bracket falls at all. Consider that in 2015 a married couple filing a joint return with taxable income of $125,000 is in the 25% federal income tax bracket. If their income in retirement is $85,000, guess what? They are still in the 25% federal tax bracket, based on current tax rates.

One strategy to consider for those of you who have been saving in a Traditional 401(k) for years, is to consider switching your future contributions into a Roth 401(k), if your plan offers it. That way when you retire you will have tax flexibility, with some of your retirement income being tax-free and some taxable.


Tag Cloud

Prime Rate Rise 2015increased auto insurance premiumcommithousing marketunsubsidized Stafford loangift not loanMinor Children 2015 record year car salessame-sex marriageretirment savingsno retirement funds for down paymentno negativitycompare monthly expensesdon't defer interest paymentsdon't ignore open enrollmentCivil RightsHow To Build Creditlow mileage discountjanuary billsbad decisionsfederal student loan deferment death benefit needs for family8 month emergency fundletter to suzeno private loansonly refinance if it payspay down car loanstrained relationshipgift grandchild IRA contributionlower premiumbetter loan ratescreate new truthmake saving a pleasure2016 adjust estimated tax8 month safety netmental healthhighest possible benefitterm insuranceHDHP protect and provide for minor child COLAGraceidentity fraudverify wellness screening and programsBill and PennyAshley Springerstaycationgay marriage ban end Florida College of Veterinary Medicinedangerous money seasonForeclosureteens and moneybuy home you can affordloan necessityAdequate Auto and Home InsuranceHDHP/HSAFinancial Gift CliffPBS SpecialSchool of Social WorkFinancial Educatorlower overall drug costCiti Simplicity Card three year car loanverify retirement plan with HR or plan sponsorautomatic withdraw to savings buy down physical healthFICO Scoresmall changes OverspendingInterestFixed Rate Mortgagecostly legal co-sign Changing LivesAlarm Clockone credit cardburn outconsider roth 401(k)raise insurance deductibleBankruptcypay off debtoverspend on dining outhome insurancedo not pay allowance for good behavior50 over 50buy homeroth iraquick closingEmergency Savingspeace of mindinsurancestudentback-to-school budgetborrow each year, capitalization is going to pile up store credit cardsno tax on withdrawlsGiftsbreakdown projected monthly housing costovercome financial fearsbest interest ratesallowancefour steps to retirement savings Durable Power of Attorney for Health Carecontribute household expenses is it necessaryemployer offered life insurancefinancing car long term goalwomen outlive menFHA loan feesvalentines daykids schedule paymentspush yourself to save more for retirementpercentage of women widowed 75-84AARP Social security calculatorwomen longer life spanLTCRevocable Living Trustearn allowanceprovider of financial supportpublic service loan forgiveness programFiscal Responsibilitytax ID theftavoid burn outmax employer matched 401(k) contributionInfluentialshome budget after tax costage appropriate choreoverspend on nights outlow down paymentjuggle multiple financial goals3 step financial road mapreal estate marketloan no longer than 36monthsMust Have DocumentsHDHP'sno waiting periodhome buying budgetcredit reportARMLong Term Care Insurance Forbes Top 10pay more than minimumget health insuranceunexpected expensewrite new goalPhyllis Shelton expert long-term careHoliday Shoppingadd teenretirementHoliday Seasonignore 6 month grace period do you need life insuranceCommunication Skills value moneyStudent Debt Crisismortgage disclosureVeterinary Schoolcalculate dependents annual income needs20 to 25 times annual incomecredit utilization rateSelfishcharges on credit cardplaninterest on student loansretirement accountsexercise reguarlypowerfulapproved medical 100% tax-freecommunity collegeEasy Life Insurance Financial Awarenessloved ones dependent on incomefinancial fearsrequire chore in exchange for allowanceSuze is my biggest mentordangerous retirement planno fee transferclosing costs 2% of loanLifestylebe good examplemax benefit coveredterm life insurance15 year mortgageis it kind?Spendinginterest capitalizationThe Suze Orman Showlong-term care premiumssuccessSuze Ormannon conventional routedepreciating asset lower rateuniversal college accessHDHP's are good for younot gender specific purely financial standpointtoo expensive schoolfraudulent returnJose RodriguezFederal Funds Rateincrease emergency savingsbecome member Bankdental insurance Willlive below your meansstudent loan debtCommencementinsurance mistakekeep a scheduledoctors in network740 credit scoreLTC shoppingbig results workaholicpositivefile asapstandard rateUniversity of Floridawould you decline a bonuscar buying mistakesdental discount planlow credit scoreno late fee emotional stakesiffy incomeStock Investmentsmortgage interest tax deductionsecure creditmax employee matchlearn good financial choicesmonthly benefit no splurge meet monthly employer funding HSAlife insurance name trust as beneficiarypreexisting condition not coveredstudent loan repayment estimatorsetup automatic savings withdrawMass Mutualsocial securityRoth 401(k)leave a legacyCredit Card Interest RateAARPmoney vowsreduce monthly paymentsocial security not going brokehigh FICO score401K10 year repayment plan Suze Orman spouse Kathy Travisstretch out haircut appointmentsRetirement Incomechildren's bookWarner Bros Television GroupGoodbyeGay Rightslong-term care Suze Orman Scholarshipbe kind to yourselfno interestAmericans don't use all paid vacation timefile taxes quicklysocial security never insolventFRAclosing disclosureFinancial Adviceface your financial fearmultiple lendersresponsiblereduce withholdinglower interest ratesummer job match income 401(k) Contributionslousy investmentpercentage men widowed 75-84Federal PLUS loanEmployer Matched Contributionmaintain standard of livingLTCi ASAPalternative FICO scorePrime Rate Increasehome related tax break bonus Conventional loan PMIdeath benefit 20 to 25 times annual incomefinancial independenceloan is giftMost Influential Celebrities Listdental savings planGiftFinancial Systemspeak new goalworst financial mistakeFinancial Power of Attorneytaxeslower mortgage interestInvest for savings growthyours, mine & oursbetter termsget credit cardcommunity bankmobile appmortgageMoney-SavingCredit Card Rate Increase20% down payment avoid fees4 Must Have Documents 3% debt transferred high down paymentcnbc alarm clockdon't derail retirement savingsExhibitionemergency fund Washingtonpoint cost offset by savingscredit cardSave Us MoneyLovepaid vacationfamily save at least $100 monthlyget the most out of social security dream schoolNewtownorigination feesInfluential Celebritylife insurancetitle insuranceinitial tax break 30 year mortgage children under 18itemized deductiononly offered while employed grandparent IRA contribution high premiumsSelectQuote.comdebtdoctor no longer in networkbudgetmonthly dental insurance premiumretirement planwomen live longeralways use all paid time offprotect dependent University of Illinois8 Rulesultimate compounding giftcouple financesNew american Dream Suze approvedmarriage inequality2017 Taxeshealthy retirement blood pressureraise deductiblesdon't buy wants3 savings buckets HDHP's are not badritual schedulebalance transfer Pay Off Debt Before RetirementYoung Adult same sex marriage band end FloridaSandy Hook Promisebe true to yourselfcar loanschedule vacationlowest cost fund optionno sneaking in feesMoneyunder 18 financial giftdon't extend mortgage tax refund fraudeight month living expense money-aware childCNBCno apologyback door Roth IRAenjoy saving Suze Orman's Money WarsAuto Savings AccuQuote.comCPI-Wage appropriate goalsgift up to 14,000insurance yearly reviewUS Tax Codecollege studentFinancial Solutions For Yourefundfocus on new truth adult children2016 adjust withholdingstudent loan repayment plancredit unionpresident ObamaFederal Stafford loanpaying for collegecostly insurance mistakeoverspend on giftsMarlo Thomassecured cardsocial workhome buying mistakespay credit debt ASAPForbeshigh deductible health care planswitch to roth 401(k)women long term careGay CouplesSuze changed my lifereplace permanent life insurance with termFinancial CliffFinancialhigh credit score discountnegotiate points with bank or sellerwives should be involved in retirementshorter payback periodrising home pricesat worst still pay 75% benefitrepay student loansreferrals traditional vs roth 401(k)Student Debtdebt freeaffordable premiumhealthy aging increase retirement contribution rateEric Dodge switch to spouse coveragemanage student loansStudent Loanproperty taxpay 100% cashtake actionWall Streetescrowhealthy youclosing feesmarriage financial responsibilityPost-Divorcenear historic lowsis it true? bad retirement planningloan big picture reduce interest rateno private loanbuying car 2016Legal GuardianBeauty!00% tuition paidFICO credit score credit card mortgagerequired disclosure3 bucket approachRevocable Trust19 years cash flow problemMotheraffordabilityshort term goal permanent life insurancelong term caremortgage brokerno life insurance financially irresponsibleconfident of solution2015 financial roadmapARM CautionNew York LifeFICO at least 720cut monthly cellular billHigh Credit Scorepaid in full20% down paymentlow-cost index mutual fundone annual feesidelineddon't charge a pennycomparison shoppingresponsible with moneyRichretain separate credit cardstelevision hostautomatic paymentCory Bookernot enough life insuranceheartacheFree Debt Eliminatorpay high rate off first6 month waiting periodlet them have 50% controlbetter loan dealsannual cost of living adjustmentsavingsspecial saving accountRetirement Savingscontribution debit cardnew carfull retirement ageStaffords this year have a fixed 6.8% interest raterent vs buyfocus on needscredit managementdon't cover cosmetic dentistrydon't spend zero rate transfer dealsCredit scorederailed planhigher monthly paymentHigh FICO Score = Better RateETF'ssave moneyadjust allocations get over life insurance phobiaschool bill paying prioritiesSatisfyingFinancial Awareness Video Festivalteens20% equitycompare provider pricingdon't do five year car loankid borrow firstfinancial goal phraseincrease retirement savingssave 40% toward financial goalprescription tierbest loan deal incentives for health care wellness screeningUrbana-ChampaignHSA tax savingsFundsFinal Goodbyeprotect loved ones One Wallet At A Timeis it necessary?identity theftteach importance of helping otherscan you afford ithome buying seasonteach your child good money habitsspring summer Personal Financeanticipated salarypay down student loan debtcost of capitalization calculatoremergency fund savingsdon't blow tax refundpublic service career student loan repayment confidentholiday spendingshop online guaranteed level term policyautomate student loan paymentsraise your deductiblecut monthly cable bill15-year refinance dealreal estate mistakesfinancial aidpremiumprotect your familyMortgage Credit Availability Indexfinancial concernHolidayhigher insurance deductible10% donate to charityTelepictureswaive home inspection bidHeartfinancial argumentsbuying a carcollege graduatepay interest while in schooldear suzegraduationstandard deduction don't use allowance as bribeknow before you oweopen enrollment review healthy retirement weightLong Term Care premiumscar leasingstudent loan repaymentVital DocumentsBaby Boomersborrowing plan advice for college graduatesstay positive20 year level term TeachSandy Hook Elementary Schoolallowance tasksavings pleasureIRA contribution gifted moneyrollovergrandchild summer job IRA contributionLong Term Care shoppingrefinancehome loan credit score below 740 Amy Lacyethome ownershipMoney Market

View Blog & News List
People First. Then Money. Then Things.
Connect with me on Facebook Connect with me on YouTube Connect with me on Twitter
© 2017 Suze Orman Media Inc. All rights reserved.
 |  Search  |  Sitemap  |  Privacy  |  Terms
Sign Up For E-mail Offers
Open Panel
Close Panel