Suze Orman TwitterSuze Orman FacebookSuze Orman YouTubeSuze Orman LinkedIn
View Blog & News List

Why You Should Seriously Consider a Roth 401(k)

July 09, 2015 at 12:00 AM

You know I love, love, love Roth IRAs. One of the prime reasons being that in retirement you will not owe a penny of tax on your withdrawals. That’s quite different from a Traditional IRA where every penny will be taxed at your ordinary income tax rate.

It wasn’t until nearly 10 years ago that 401(k) plans were allowed to offer a Roth version. Today about half of plans currently give employees the option of saving in a Traditional 401(k) or a Roth 401(k). Yet very few employees are opting for the Roth 401(k).

I think that can be a shortsighted mistake.

Yes, it’s absolutely true that there is an upfront tax break when you save in a Traditional 401(k) that you don’t get with a Roth 401(k). Every dollar you contribute to a Traditional account reduces your taxable income for that year. But money you put into a Roth account is made with after-tax dollars, so there is no “upfront” tax break.

I get that the tax break right now can be appealing. But what you need to carefully consider is the long-term impact-or tradeoff-of that decision. As I mentioned, all money withdrawn from a Traditional 401(k) will be taxed at your ordinary income tax rate, while there will be no tax on withdrawals from a Roth 401(k).

I think the prospect of no taxes in retirement on your retirement withdrawals is well worth considering. One of the common rules of thumb is to go with the Roth only if you expect your tax rate in retirement to be lower than your tax rate today. I’ve got two issues with that.

First, who knows where tax rates will be 10, 20, 30 years from now? I have to tell you that today’s rates are a lot lower than when I started my financial planning career.

Second, even though your income will likely be less in retirement, that doesn’t mean you automatically will be in a much lower tax bracket, if your bracket falls at all. Consider that in 2015 a married couple filing a joint return with taxable income of $125,000 is in the 25% federal income tax bracket. If their income in retirement is $85,000, guess what? They are still in the 25% federal tax bracket, based on current tax rates.

One strategy to consider for those of you who have been saving in a Traditional 401(k) for years, is to consider switching your future contributions into a Roth 401(k), if your plan offers it. That way when you retire you will have tax flexibility, with some of your retirement income being tax-free and some taxable.


Tag Cloud

bill paying prioritiessocial workdental insurance student loan repayment planstretch out haircut appointmentsincrease retirement contribution rateautomatic paymentdear suzemax benefit coveredlow mileage discountpublic service career student loan repayment worst financial mistakelower ratePost-Divorceproperty taxpresident ObamaFRAMotherjuggle multiple financial goalsrent vs buyshop online guaranteed level term policydon't buy wantsworkaholicincreased auto insurance premiumaccelerate dental work20 to 25 times annual income8 Rulesdepreciating asset powerful8 month emergency funddon't charge a pennyHSA tax savingsdental discount planwrite new goalenjoy saving Prime Rate Rise 2015Amy Lacyetthree year car loanno late fee responsible with moneylife insuranceFHA loan fees3 savings buckets ARMnot gender specific Gay RightsstudentAdequate Auto and Home InsuranceFederal Funds Ratefinancial concernmake saving a pleasuresuccessdon't extend mortgage ETF'smortgage interest tax deductionFinancial Cliffdon't cover cosmetic dentistrycnbc alarm clockSandy Hook PromiseFixed Rate MortgageGiftpay off debtkid borrow firstBankruptcyallowance taskHoliday ShoppingHDHP/HSAone annual feefraudulent returnHow To Build Creditfamily save at least $100 monthlycredit reportlousy investmentreduce monthly paymentstore credit cardstake actionPBS Specialdeath benefit needs for familyearn more on savingsspeak new goalfour steps to retirement savings iffy incomebetter termscar buying mistakeslet them have 50% controlbetter loan ratesbig results Financialat worst still pay 75% benefitfinancial argumentsbe kind to yourselfcouple financeschildren's bookloan big picture Retirement Incomegrandchild summer job IRA contributiondebt free19 years cash flow problemrequire chore in exchange for allowanceadvice for college graduatesritual schedulesecure creditmarriage financial responsibilitySelectQuote.comFundsStaffords this year have a fixed 6.8% interest rateSatisfyingCOLAhigher insurance deductiblecredit managementMarlo Thomaswomen live longerCivil RightsStudent Debt Crisishigher monthly paymentcollege graduateSuze changed my lifeWashingtonhome buying mistakesshort term goal University of Illinoiscost of capitalization calculatorNew american Dream know before you oweoverspend on dining outFiscal Responsibilityunder 18 financial gifttitle insurancereduce interest rateloan no longer than 36monthsignore 6 month grace period Credit score2017 TaxesYoung Adult Financial Solutions For Youhome related tax break bonus InterestPrime Rate Increaseadjust allocations Foreclosurepay high rate off firstVeterinary Schooldebit cardsetup automatic savings withdrawrepay student loansno interestLong Term Care Insurance rising home pricesdangerous retirement plancan you afford it8 month safety netGiftsRoth 401(k)3 bucket approachfocus on new truth Death Benefitmortgagehousing marketPay Off Debt Before Retirementswitch to roth 401(k)Inflation BenefitEmployer Matched Contributionverify retirement plan with HR or plan sponsorone credit cardInvest for savings growthHDHP initial tax break 401(k) Contributionsfile taxes quicklyloan necessityapproved medical 100% tax-freehome buying seasononly offered while employed Stock InvestmentsTelepicturesrequired disclosure2016 adjust withholdingMass Mutualstudent loan repayment estimatorsave moneyExhibition10 year repayment plan home buying budgetCPI-Wdon't spend Money-Savingescrowbuy down closing feesgrandparent IRA contribution money-aware childstrained relationshipDurable Power of Attorney for Health Care20% equityretirement accountsdoctor no longer in networkOne Wallet At A Timeinterest on student loansFICO credit score credit card mortgageSelfishretain separate credit cardsPersonal Financewomen longer life spanBeautyMust Have Documentshealthy retirement blood pressureretirment savingsplanprotect dependent protect your familyteenspay more than minimumbuy home you can affordPhyllis Shelton expert long-term care30 year mortgage 40% toward financial goalfinancial fearspoint cost offset by savings6 month waiting periodAlarm Clockbuying car 2016high FICO scoremultiple lendersNew York Lifelower overall drug costpublic service loan forgiveness programmoney vowsFree Debt EliminatorInfluentialsnot enough life insurancebalance transfer don't blow tax refundBaby Boomerseliminate credit card debtFinancial Systemhealthy youleave a legacyheartachedream schoolface your financial fearunexpected expensedebtborrowing plan protect loved ones Suze approvedsocial security not going brokeInfluential Celebrityinsuranceraising interest rateszero rate transfer dealsemergency fund savingslong term carenew carpay credit debt ASAPdangerous money seasonMortgage Credit Availability IndexIRA contribution gifted moneylong term goalprovider of financial supportThe Suze Orman ShowBill and PennyLovebudgetno fee transferFinal Goodbyehighest possible benefitemotional stakesget over life insurance phobiaorigination feeswomen long term carepush yourself to save more for retirementHolidayteach your child good money habitsWill20 year level term near historic lowsLTC shoppingretirement plansave Wall Streetlow credit scoreAshley Springerstudent loan repaymenthigh premiumsno splurge too expensive schoolpurely financial standpointcontribute household expenses Communication Skills only refinance if it paysadd teen740 credit scoreWarner Bros Television Groupno waiting periodRetirement Savingshome budget after tax costearn allowanceHDHP's are good for you50 over 50healthy gumsdon't use allowance as bribepercentage of women widowed 75-84summer job match income refinancecommitMoneySuze Orman spouse Kathy Travistelevision hostCommencementraising mortgage rates 3 step financial road maphome insuranceFICO Scoreclosing costs 2% of loanHigh Credit Scoreemergency fund alternative FICO scorewaive home inspection bidreplace permanent life insurance with termjanuary billsLong Term Care shoppingSpendingpositiveno tax on withdrawlscalculate dependents annual income needsMinor Children paying for collegeHoliday SeasonrefundSandy Hook Elementary Schoolgift up to 14,000social securityprotect and provide for minor child meet monthly social security never insolventCiti Simplicity Card get the most out of social security death benefit 20 to 25 times annual incomehealthy aging is it necessary?4 Must Have Documents kids schedule paymentshigh deductible health care planroth iraCNBCbe good exampleSave Us Moneyincentives for health care wellness screeningsame sex marriage band end FloridaTeachstandard rateEmergency Savingsfile asaplower mortgage interestcostly legal eight month living expense US Tax CodeLegal Guardianno sneaking in fees3% debt transferred no negativitycredit unionconsider roth 401(k)holiday spendingFinancial Educatorvalue moneylower premiumhome loan credit score below 740 manage student loansloved ones dependent on incomemarriage inequalityhigh down paymentterm life insurancecreate new truthfinancing car best loan deal confidentretirementterm insurancesmall changes employer offered life insurancebuying a carlearn good financial choicesSuze Orman Scholarshipidentity frauddental savings planstudent loan debtSuze is my biggest mentoroverspend on giftsSwap Older Annuities or Life Insurance back-to-school budgetCory BookerCD'sFinancial Power of Attorneymortgage disclosureStudent Loanget health insurancemental healthshorter payback periodCombo Insurance Productsmax employee matchstaycationswitch to spouse coverageGraceHDHP'sovercome financial fearsis it true? pay 100% cashno apologyraise insurance deductibleincrease retirement savingsloan is giftSchool of Social Worktax ID theftraise deductiblesmonthly dental insurance premiumkeep a schedulegay marriage ban end Florida Revocable Trustburn outpaid vacationbecome member automate student loan paymentswould you decline a bonusteens and moneyclosing disclosureinterest capitalization2015 financial roadmapAmericans don't use all paid vacation timeno private loanCredit Card Interest RateGoodbyeAuto Savings employer funding HSAhealthy retirement weightyours, mine & oursnegotiate points with bank or sellerultimate compounding giftdon't ignore open enrollmentpaid in fullFinancial Gift Cliffcredit cardmonthly benefit bad retirement planning15-year refinance dealgift grandchild IRA contributionquick closingmortgage brokerspecial saving accounthealthy teeth2015 record year car salescut monthly cable billcommunity collegefinancial goal phrasecompare monthly expensesmax employer matched 401(k) contributionSuze Orman's Money Warsrollovercompare provider pricinglow down paymentAARP Social security calculatorHeart401KBankNewtownno life insurance financially irresponsibleget credit cardsavingsdon't do five year car loancredit utilization ratenon conventional routereal estate marketpeace of mindFederal Stafford loanCredit Card Rate Increasefull retirement agesecured cardallowanceLTCi ASAP10% donate to charityOverspendingsame-sex marriageConventional loan PMILTCannual cost of living adjustmentanticipated salaryraise your deductibleinsurance yearly reviewconfident of solutionvalentines dayautomatic withdraw to savings breakdown projected monthly housing costsavings pleasureidentity theftavoid burn outletter to suzereduce withholdingcontribution pay down student loan debtLong Term Care premiumsAARPJose RodriguezaffordabilityChanging LivesRevocable Living Trustdon't derail retirement savings!00% tuition paidpermanent life insuranceUniversity of Floridapreexisting condition not coveredstay positivedon't defer interest paymentsreal estate mistakesincrease emergency savingsborrow each year, capitalization is going to pile up unsubsidized Stafford loanForbesFinancial Awareness Video FestivalAccuQuote.commobile appcomparison shoppingderailed planalways use all paid time offadult childrenlong-term care do not pay allowance for good behaviorage appropriate choreinsurance mistakelive below your meansage appropriate goalsresponsibleverify wellness screening and programspay down car loanhome ownershipbad decisionsmaintain standard of livinglower interest ratesidelinedStudent Debtfederal student loan deferment no private loansUrbana-Champaignchildren under 18spring summer 20% down payment avoid feesdo you need life insurancelong-term care premiumsno retirement funds for down paymentFederal Reservetraditional vs roth 401(k)Suze OrmanGay CouplesRichis it kind?referrals overspend on nights outbuy homecollege studentpercentage men widowed 75-84Easy Life Insurance better loan dealsopen enrollment review costly insurance mistakewomen outlive menschedule vacationdoctors in networkexercise reguarlytax refund fraudForbes Top 10charges on credit cardMost Influential Celebrities Listwives should be involved in retirementis it necessarygift not loanHigh FICO Score = Better RateLifestyleFederal PLUS loanco-sign low-cost index mutual fundstandard deduction universal college accesscar leasingVital Documentsfocus on needspay interest while in schoolfinancial aidgraduationhigh credit score discountCollege of Veterinary Medicine2016 adjust estimated taxFICO at least 720Financial Awarenessitemized deduction15 year mortgageaffordable premiumHDHP's are not badcut monthly cellular billschool Money Market20% down paymentteach importance of helping othersprescription tiertaxesbe true to yourselfpremiumEric Dodge best interest rateslowest cost fund optionfinancial independencephysical healthback door Roth IRAFinancial Advicecommunity banklife insurance name trust as beneficiarycar loanARM Caution

View Blog & News List
People First. Then Money. Then Things.
Connect with me on Facebook Connect with me on YouTube Connect with me on Twitter
© 2017 Suze Orman Media Inc. All rights reserved.
 |  Search  |  Sitemap  |  Privacy  |  Terms
Sign Up For E-mail Offers
Open Panel
Close Panel