Suze Orman TwitterSuze Orman FacebookSuze Orman YouTubeSuze Orman LinkedIn
View Blog & News List

Why You Should Seriously Consider a Roth 401(k)

July 09, 2015 at 12:00 AM

You know I love, love, love Roth IRAs. One of the prime reasons being that in retirement you will not owe a penny of tax on your withdrawals. That’s quite different from a Traditional IRA where every penny will be taxed at your ordinary income tax rate.

It wasn’t until nearly 10 years ago that 401(k) plans were allowed to offer a Roth version. Today about half of plans currently give employees the option of saving in a Traditional 401(k) or a Roth 401(k). Yet very few employees are opting for the Roth 401(k).

I think that can be a shortsighted mistake.

Yes, it’s absolutely true that there is an upfront tax break when you save in a Traditional 401(k) that you don’t get with a Roth 401(k). Every dollar you contribute to a Traditional account reduces your taxable income for that year. But money you put into a Roth account is made with after-tax dollars, so there is no “upfront” tax break.

I get that the tax break right now can be appealing. But what you need to carefully consider is the long-term impact-or tradeoff-of that decision. As I mentioned, all money withdrawn from a Traditional 401(k) will be taxed at your ordinary income tax rate, while there will be no tax on withdrawals from a Roth 401(k).

I think the prospect of no taxes in retirement on your retirement withdrawals is well worth considering. One of the common rules of thumb is to go with the Roth only if you expect your tax rate in retirement to be lower than your tax rate today. I’ve got two issues with that.

First, who knows where tax rates will be 10, 20, 30 years from now? I have to tell you that today’s rates are a lot lower than when I started my financial planning career.

Second, even though your income will likely be less in retirement, that doesn’t mean you automatically will be in a much lower tax bracket, if your bracket falls at all. Consider that in 2015 a married couple filing a joint return with taxable income of $125,000 is in the 25% federal income tax bracket. If their income in retirement is $85,000, guess what? They are still in the 25% federal tax bracket, based on current tax rates.

One strategy to consider for those of you who have been saving in a Traditional 401(k) for years, is to consider switching your future contributions into a Roth 401(k), if your plan offers it. That way when you retire you will have tax flexibility, with some of your retirement income being tax-free and some taxable.


Tag Cloud

enjoy saving 2015 record year car salesCiti Simplicity Card lower overall drug costback door Roth IRAHSA tax savingsone annual feeInfluential Celebrityhome related tax break bonus comparison shoppingcompare monthly expensesLong Term Care premiumsSuze Orman Scholarshipsummer job match income term life insurancecar leasingMoney Marketapproved medical 100% tax-freeHDHP/HSAincrease retirement contribution ratepay more than minimumSuze Ormanexercise reguarlyYoung Adult borrow each year, capitalization is going to pile up standard deduction Long Term Care shoppingconfident of solutionsidelinedBaby Boomerssame-sex marriageopen enrollment review alternative FICO scoregrandchild summer job IRA contributioncredit utilization rateis it true? OverspendingSandy Hook Elementary Schoolswitch to roth 401(k)taxesPay Off Debt Before RetirementDurable Power of Attorney for Health Caretitle insurancefinancial independencecostly insurance mistakeGiftsdo you need life insurancemarriage inequalitypreexisting condition not covereddear suzeFederal Funds Rategay marriage ban end Florida long term goalidentity frauddental discount planSelectQuote.comwomen long term caresame sex marriage band end FloridaFICO Scorehigh FICO scoreRichMotherUniversity of Floridabecome member 2017 Taxescut monthly cable billmortgage disclosurecommunity collegeCommencementconsider roth 401(k)refinanceclosing disclosureMortgage Credit Availability Indexraise your deductiblegift grandchild IRA contributionhighest possible benefitshop online guaranteed level term policyJose Rodriguezanticipated salarydangerous retirement planreferrals mortgage interest tax deductioncommunity bank3% debt transferred yours, mine & oursfinancial goal phraseGoodbyecredit management15-year refinance dealincentives for health care wellness screeningBankruptcyvalentines dayno tax on withdrawls740 credit scoremortgagesave lower mortgage interestrising home pricessocial security never insolventgrandparent IRA contribution protect and provide for minor child protect loved ones january billslow-cost index mutual fundwould you decline a bonus3 step financial road mappaid in fullEmergency Savingscredit cardteensonly refinance if it paysrent vs buyreplace permanent life insurance with termUS Tax Codeemployer offered life insurancewomen longer life spanSuze Orman spouse Kathy Travisdoctor no longer in networkresponsiblebalance transfer no retirement funds for down paymentlow credit scoretax ID theftpremiumdon't defer interest paymentsdental savings planitemized deductionhigh premiumsmax benefit coveredpay down car loanFinal GoodbyeSpendingemotional stakesGracesavingsborrowing plan quick closingIRA contribution gifted moneyAccuQuote.commanage student loansdangerous money seasonCredit Card Rate Increaseultimate compounding giftfile taxes quicklyThe Suze Orman Showprotect your familycar buying mistakeslet them have 50% controlinsurancesecure creditHow To Build Creditcredit unionpermanent life insuranceFinancial Solutions For Youdebt freeStaffords this year have a fixed 6.8% interest ratedon't cover cosmetic dentistryLifestyleadjust allocations paid vacationcreate new truthadd teenbe true to yourselfMarlo Thomasstaycationstudent loan repaymentemployer funding HSAtake actionhigh deductible health care planbe kind to yourselfmoney-aware childdeath benefit needs for family2016 adjust estimated taxget credit cardsavings pleasureno splurge graduationfinancing car AARP Social security calculatorHolidayConventional loan PMIHoliday ShoppingSave Us Moneylong term carehome insuranceretirement accountsinterest on student loanssecured cardhome buying seasonlower premiumshort term goal FRApay down student loan debtbetter loan dealsletter to suzereduce interest ratefinancial concernmake saving a pleasure4 Must Have Documents automate student loan paymentsHeartAdequate Auto and Home Insurancekeep a scheduleconfidentloan necessityRetirement Incomedental insurance 50 over 50FICO credit score credit card mortgagecnbc alarm clockLTCderailed planSchool of Social Workdoctors in networkNew american Dream don't ignore open enrollmentUniversity of IllinoisSuze Orman's Money Warsearn allowancePBS Specialbuying car 2016under 18 financial giftsetup automatic savings withdrawback-to-school budgetloan is gift2016 adjust withholdingmaintain standard of livingno private loanthree year car loanStudent Debtpublic service loan forgiveness programvalue moneycost of capitalization calculatorlife insurancedon't spend stay positiveWashingtonfraudulent returncollege studenthigh credit score discountwrite new goalCollege of Veterinary Medicinepercentage of women widowed 75-84InfluentialsworkaholicSuze is my biggest mentorBankzero rate transfer dealsbe good exampleAmy Lacyetloan big picture responsible with money20 year level term identity theftuniversal college accesspoint cost offset by savingsbuy home you can afford19 years cash flow problemspeak new goalSandy Hook Promisesocial workverify retirement plan with HR or plan sponsormobile appVeterinary Schoolgift not loanschool retirement planWall Streetstore credit cardsincreased auto insurance premiumLTCi ASAPdon't derail retirement savingsbad retirement planningmultiple lenderskid borrow firstwomen live longerchildren under 18not gender specific debit cardmental healthLovewaive home inspection bidInvest for savings growthCivil RightsInterestignore 6 month grace period lower ratewomen outlive menmax employee matchworst financial mistakeallowanceCory Bookerlow mileage discountannual cost of living adjustmentovercome financial fears3 savings buckets raise deductiblesFinancial Gift Cliffrolloverdon't extend mortgage New York LifeFundsteens and moneypositiveterm insurancereduce monthly paymentLTC shoppinghealthy retirement blood pressurepublic service career student loan repayment can you afford itEasy Life Insurance require chore in exchange for allowanceAuto Savings budgetno life insurance financially irresponsibleOne Wallet At A TimeplanAARPFiscal Responsibilitynear historic lowsfour steps to retirement savings retain separate credit cardsForbes Top 10pay interest while in schoolStudent Debt Crisisno apologycompare provider pricingget the most out of social security 20 to 25 times annual incomespecial saving accounttelevision hostpay high rate off firstSatisfyinghome ownershipCredit scoreknow before you oweLong Term Care Insurance focus on needsunsubsidized Stafford loanSuze changed my lifeno waiting periodCommunication Skills 10 year repayment plan Changing LivesFinancialnew carcharges on credit cardburn outage appropriate chorehigher insurance deductible10% donate to charityMost Influential Celebrities Listjuggle multiple financial goalsPost-Divorce20% down payment avoid feesbuy homeWarner Bros Television GroupNewtownat worst still pay 75% benefit20% equityRevocable Living Trustgift up to 14,000no fee transfer8 month emergency fundbuying a carTelepicturesincrease emergency savingspay off debt2015 financial roadmapmeet monthly learn good financial choicesswitch to spouse coveragefull retirement age3 bucket approachRoth 401(k)don't use allowance as bribeForbesprotect dependent HDHP'sdon't blow tax refundsave moneyinsurance yearly reviewlowest cost fund optionhome budget after tax costlousy investmentalways use all paid time offadult childrenCNBCStock InvestmentsUrbana-Champaignretirementaffordable premiumRetirement Savingspowerfulno interestis it necessary!00% tuition paidbad decisionsAshley Springertax refund fraudpresident ObamaHDHP's are not badhigh down paymentdepreciating asset marriage financial responsibilitystudent loan debtstandard ratecar loandebtpaying for collegePersonal FinanceExhibitioncouple financesFinancial Power of Attorneyincrease retirement savingspay credit debt ASAPbetter termsfinancial fears6 month waiting periodinitial tax break Americans don't use all paid vacation timeprovider of financial supportstudent loan repayment estimatorpurely financial standpointhealthy aging is it kind?age appropriate goals8 month safety netCPI-Wcollege graduatehome loan credit score below 740 Holiday Seasonloved ones dependent on incomefocus on new truth no negativityteach importance of helping othersfederal student loan deferment social security not going brokeproperty taxspring summer Financial Cliffmonthly benefit dream schoolstretch out haircut appointmentsretirment savingsiffy incomePhyllis Shelton expert long-term careinsurance mistakenot enough life insurancelow down payment401(k) Contributionsmortgage brokercommitFinancial Adviceoverspend on giftsraise insurance deductibleinterest capitalizationSuze approvedbest interest ratescut monthly cellular billFinancial Awarenessnegotiate points with bank or sellerlive below your meansCOLAemergency fund savingsescrowhome buying mistakesForeclosureritual scheduleautomatic withdraw to savings family save at least $100 monthlyget over life insurance phobiaface your financial fearavoid burn outget health insuranceunexpected expenseMoneyGay Rightsemergency fund only offered while employed holiday spendingHDHP Prime Rate IncreaseHDHP's are good for youCredit Card Interest Ratehealthy youbreakdown projected monthly housing costpush yourself to save more for retirement401Kbetter loan ratesoverspend on dining outcontribute household expenses credit reportGay Couples20% down paymentGiftFree Debt Eliminatortraditional vs roth 401(k)Beautyloan no longer than 36monthssmall changes successhousing marketdon't buy wantsstudentcontribution verify wellness screening and programsFinancial Awareness Video Festivalorigination feesno late fee co-sign closing costs 2% of loanschedule vacationallowance taskclosing feesmoney vowsdeath benefit 20 to 25 times annual incomeAlarm ClockPrime Rate Rise 2015ETF'sstrained relationshipfinancial argumentsdo not pay allowance for good behaviorEmployer Matched Contributionlong-term care premiumsrequired disclosureprescription tierlife insurance name trust as beneficiaryFinancial Educatorrefundoverspend on nights outrepay student loanspay 100% cashchildren's bookFICO at least 720percentage men widowed 75-84real estate marketautomatic paymentheartacheno sneaking in feesStudent Loanbest loan deal 40% toward financial goalreal estate mistakes8 Rulesbuy down calculate dependents annual income needsdon't do five year car loanBill and Pennyleave a legacyEric Dodge big results is it necessary?FHA loan feesdon't charge a pennyphysical healthMass MutualMoney-Savingmonthly dental insurance premiumsocial securitymax employer matched 401(k) contributionadvice for college graduatesone credit cardTeachteach your child good money habitsFinancial Systemhome buying budgetfile asapbill paying prioritiesreduce withholdingstudent loan repayment planpeace of mindwives should be involved in retirementroth irahealthy retirement weightkids schedule paymentslong-term care

View Blog & News List
People First. Then Money. Then Things.
Connect with me on Facebook Connect with me on YouTube Connect with me on Twitter
© 2017 Suze Orman Media Inc. All rights reserved.
 |  Search  |  Sitemap  |  Privacy  |  Terms
Sign Up For E-mail Offers
Open Panel
Close Panel