Suze Orman TwitterSuze Orman FacebookSuze Orman YouTubeSuze Orman LinkedIn
View Blog & News List

How to Deal with a Rate Increase on Your Long-Term Care Insurance Policy

September 23, 2016 at 12:00 AM

Many of you are asking me what to do when you receive a rate increase on your long-term care insurance policy. You know my advice for years has been to not buy long-term care insurance unless you can afford a 50% rate increase in your lifetime. I never thought I would be discussing a 126% rate increase which is how much some Federal LTC Insurance Program (FLTCIP) policyholders are facing, with an average of 83%. The Federal program policyholders have to make a decision by September 30th so that’s why I’m writing this blog now.

How could this happen? This decision was based on four main things:

  1. Actual claims experience – the most recent claims study said women who need LTC longer than a year need an average of 4.7 years of care, whereas men need only 3.8 years. The “country-club” assisted living facilities have made this longer. People live longer when they are happy!
  2. The demographic reality that people are living longer, and the longer people live, the more likely they are to file a claim. 
  3. Low lapse rate which means most people don’t cancel their policies, even when they get rate increases.
  4. The low interest rate environment we are in has reduced present and future investment income on the money held in reserve to pay claims.
John Hancock, the carrier behind the Federal program, believes the new rates will be enough to pay future claims and doesn’t anticipate another rate increase but they aren’t going to guarantee that of course.

Now, everyone who got a rate increase got a letter to lower the benefits to either take a smaller rate increase (still over 50%) or take no rate increase and keep the premium the same. There’s also an option to let the policy go and receive benefits equal to the premium you have paid in if you ever need LTC. 

So I turned to Phyllis Shelton, my go-to person for long-term care insurance for what she thinks you should do. She said for sure not to let the policy go. Here is what she is telling people to do about any rate increase, not just the Federal program:

Depending on your age and how long you think you will live based on your family history and overall health, figure out how much benefit you will need in the future. Then figure out how much premium you will pay if you accept the rate increase over the next 20 or 30 years. Add that to what you have already paid, and compare the total premium to what the benefits will be at that same point. She says the premium is usually about 10% of the future benefits and to not forget that you get to stop paying your premium when you start receiving benefits. If you look at lowering your benefits, she says to compare the premium savings with the future benefits you will lose.

“That’s the only way they can make an informed decision, Suze.” I asked her for an example, and after reading it, it sounds like one of my “Can you afford it?” shows!

  • “Nancy” is 64 years old and has many family members who live to their mid-90s, but no Alzheimer’s in her family history. 
  • She lives in Austin, TX and a “country-club” assisted living facility costs about $6,000 a month today. At 5% compound inflation, it will cost about $20,000 a month in 25 years. Nursing home care will cost more, so it would be good if her insurance policy could pay for a nice assisted living facility and a lot of home care. Then she could use her savings to pay the difference if she needs nursing home care as a last resort.
  • Her current benefits are $220.50 a day ($6,700 a month) and a 5 year benefit period which gives her a benefit pool today of $402,412, and 5% compound inflation which will grow her benefits in 25 years to $22,700 a month and a benefit pool of $1.3 million.
  • Her current premium is $323 a month and is increasing to $536 a month, a 66% rate increase, which she is adamant she can’t afford.
  • Based on the new rate, she will wind up paying $165,000 in total premium in 25 years vs. $1.3 million in benefits at that time.
  • The letter gave her an option to reduce her inflation from 5% to 3% and keep her premium the same.
  • The 3% compound inflation means her benefit will grow to $14,000 in 25 years, a huge shortfall for the nice assisted living facility which will cost about $20,000 at that time.
  • She is smart and knows she doesn’t have to accept just what the letter said, so she asked for the premium to keep her 5% inflation but reduce her benefit period from five years to three years. That premium is $308 a month, even lower than her current premium. This is the one she is thinking about.
  • This option will save her $228 a month [new premium $536-$308], which is $68,400 over 25 years, but she will lose $545,500 in benefits [monthly benefit in 25 years $22,700 x 3 years = $817,200 vs. $1,362,710 for 5 years]
  • RESULT: She is accepting the rate increase, especially because she now understands she will always have the option to reduce from 5 years to 3 years if she gets another rate increase.

Don’t want to go through all that? Here’s the short version:

  1. Compare the premium you have already paid plus the premium you will pay if you accept the rate increase to the benefits you will have at age 85. Use this compound inflation calculator. 
  2. If you aren’t satisfied with the difference, take the second option offered to you.

Still need help? Phyllis has agreed to help you as a personal favor to me.

Tag Cloud

credit cardStock Investmentsinitial tax break origination feesfocus on needslow down paymentretirement accountsemotional stakeshealthy retirement weightFederal PLUS loanpreexisting condition not coveredAuto Savings save healthy teeth8 month safety netGiftsHDHP keep a schedulepremiumFICO Scorechildren's bookdangerous money seasonconfident of solutionprovider of financial supportknow before you owetelevision host20 to 25 times annual incomenear historic lowsreduce withholdingForbes Top 10is it necessarylow mileage discountHDHP's are not badGoodbyelearn good financial choicesfinancial goal phraseStudent Debt Crisisloan necessitynon conventional routelet them have 50% controlGiftbig results high down payment!00% tuition paidFederal Stafford loandeath benefit 20 to 25 times annual incomeoverspend on giftsco-sign University of Illinoiscar loanfederal student loan deferment One Wallet At A Timemanage student loansprotect and provide for minor child negotiate points with bank or sellerstore credit cardsSpendingrolloverTelepicturesmortgageFixed Rate Mortgageat worst still pay 75% benefitshop online guaranteed level term policyswitch to spouse coveragedebtworkaholicadvice for college graduatesget over life insurance phobiayours, mine & oursdon't defer interest paymentscnbc alarm clockreal estate mistakesborrow each year, capitalization is going to pile up tax refund fraud2015 record year car salesuniversal college accesswould you decline a bonusno waiting periodstandard deduction don't derail retirement savingsmoney-aware childHoliday Shoppinglowest cost fund optionraising interest ratesPhyllis Shelton expert long-term caregraduationWashingtonFiscal Responsibilityiffy incomefour steps to retirement savings eliminate credit card debtearn more on savingsCD's20% down paymentPay Off Debt Before RetirementSandy Hook Elementary SchoolHoliday Season15 year mortgagelow credit scoreInvest for savings growthConventional loan PMIbuy down new carinterest capitalizationIRA contribution gifted moneySuze Orman Scholarshipannual cost of living adjustmentfamily save at least $100 monthly3 step financial road mapdoctors in networkraise your deductibleFinancial Adviceritual schedulebe good example6 month waiting periodconfidentpaid in fullcommissionscompare monthly expensesdental savings planCombo Insurance Productsdream schoolRoth 401(k)no apologyconsider roth 401(k)Easy Life Insurance Cory Bookerpowerfulwomen long term careAlarm Clockemployer funding HSAis it kind?Bill and Pennybill paying priorities2016 adjust estimated taxdear suzedental discount planaffordable premiumstudent loan repayment estimatorMoney10 year repayment plan bad retirement planningcredit managementprotect dependent no late fee Urbana-ChampaignMost Influential Celebrities Listmonthly dental insurance premium10% donate to charitydon't buy wantsfinancial aidbecome member pay high rate off firstinterest on student loans50 over 50cut monthly cellular billInfluential Celebrityhealthy youcredit reportEmployer Matched Contributionitemized deductionFinancial Systemalways use all paid time offAARP Social security calculatorFinancial Educatorcommunity collegedon't blow tax refundlousy investmentaccelerate dental workadjust allocations Post-Divorceclosing disclosurecollege graduateinsurancederailed planrefinanceSatisfyinglong-term care cut monthly cable billincrease retirement contribution ratebuying car 2016professional advisorLoveFree Debt Eliminatorlower interest ratejuggle multiple financial goalsrefund401(k) Contributionsproperty taxshort term goal contribution studenthome buying seasonignore 6 month grace period only refinance if it payshome budget after tax costinsurance mistakesocial security not going brokeHSA tax savingsverify wellness screening and programscharges on credit cardhigh deductible health care planGay Rightsfocus on new truth Inflation Benefitdoctor no longer in networkbuy home you can affordrequire chore in exchange for allowanceFinal Goodbyeno sneaking in feesSelfishsocial workhome buying budgetpoint cost offset by savingsCNBCFinancial Solutions For YoutaxesCredit Card Rate Increaseloved ones dependent on incomeclosing costs 2% of loandebit cardmental healthSandy Hook Promisebetter loan dealsAshley SpringerMoney-SavingAARPhome insuranceForbesenjoy saving BankruptcyUniversity of FloridaFinancial Cliffstudent loan repaymentidentity theft3% debt transferred pay 100% cashCOLAteensLong Term Care Insurance social security3 savings buckets 30 year mortgage higher monthly paymentHeartsidelinedlower premiumfinancial fearsface your financial fearFederal Reservemarriage financial responsibilityapproved medical 100% tax-freepresident Obamakid borrow firstEric Dodge alternative FICO scoreOverspendingSwap Older Annuities or Life Insurance heartachespecial saving accountfinancing car percentage of women widowed 75-84reduce monthly paymentchildren under 18waive home inspection bidlong term careno private loanssave moneystay positiveengaged in financesno negativityraising mortgage rates Death Benefitavoid burn outpaid vacationwrite new goalone credit cardspeak new goalfinancial argumentsForeclosuregrandchild summer job IRA contributionExhibition20 year level term age appropriate choreloan big picture unexpected expensemeet monthly HDHP'slower mortgage interestnot gender specific Prime Rate Rise 2015mobile appcollege studentovercome financial fearsETF'sCredit Card Interest Rateno private loanincentives for health care wellness screeningCiti Simplicity Card zero rate transfer dealsback door Roth IRAVeterinary Schoollower ratePrime Rate Increasefinancial independenceis it true? tax ID theftMortgage Credit Availability IndexMoney MarketHDHP/HSAborrowing plan not enough life insuranceMass MutualLong Term Care shoppingfraudulent returnFICO credit score credit card mortgageloan is giftcommunity bankhome buying mistakesSuze Orman's Money Warsterm insurancebetter termsDurable Power of Attorney for Health CareNew american Dream women outlive menmax employer matched 401(k) contributioncredit unionautomatic withdraw to savings Adequate Auto and Home Insurancehighest possible benefitmoney vowswives should be involved in retirementno retirement funds for down paymentcan you afford itMust Have DocumentsPersonal Financeincreased auto insurance premiumincrease retirement savingsoverspend on dining outquick closingvalentines dayRetirement Income8 month emergency fundoverspend on nights outSuze Orman spouse Kathy Travisschedule vacationstudent loan debtonly offered while employed allowance taskfinancial concernNewtownjanuary bills40% toward financial goalUS Tax CodeHigh Credit Scoreretirement planChanging Lives401Kpay off debtdon't extend mortgage increase emergency savingsbe true to yourselfstandard ratepublic service loan forgiveness programget credit cardFederal Funds RateHDHP's are good for youopen enrollment review savings pleasuredangerous retirement planstrained relationshipis it necessary?gift up to 14,000don't charge a pennygrandparent IRA contribution High FICO Score = Better Raterepay student loansSuze approvedcar leasingcouple financesloan no longer than 36monthsRetirement Savingsbudgetdepreciating asset 2017 Taxes2015 financial roadmaproth irarent vs buy19 years cash flow problemphysical healthFundsfull retirement ageidentity fraudpay down car loaninsurance yearly reviewcomparison shoppingmake saving a pleasureunder 18 financial giftresponsiblereplace permanent life insurance with termrequired disclosurecommitFRAInfluentialsYoung Adult value moneyLegal Guardiantoo expensive schooladult childrenmultiple lendersmarriage inequalitybuy homeLTC shoppingbe kind to yourselfpay interest while in schoolspring summer reduce interest ratedebt freepay credit debt ASAPRevocable Trustcreate new truthInteresthealthy gumsschool Teachteach your child good money habitsprotect loved ones teach importance of helping othersEmergency Savingsmortgage disclosuretitle insurancetraditional vs roth 401(k)high premiumskids schedule paymentsFinancial Awareness Video Festivalshorter payback periodemployer offered life insuranceearn allowanceunsubsidized Stafford loanGracerising home priceshome loan credit score below 740 Civil Rightscost of capitalization calculatordon't use allowance as bribeget the most out of social security staycationgay marriage ban end Florida file asapleave a legacysuitableStudent DebtWillcostly insurance mistakeARM CautionVital Documentsemergency fund savingstake actionSuze is my biggest mentorAmy LacyetMarlo Thomashigh FICO scoreLifestylehigh credit score discountpermanent life insuranceworst financial mistakepositivepeace of mindStudent Loanage appropriate goalsreal estate marketmax employee matchHolidayThe Suze Orman ShowNew York LifeRich20% down payment avoid feesdon't spend setup automatic savings withdrawmaintain standard of livingbalance transfer paying for collegecalculate dependents annual income needsRevocable Living Truststudent loan repayment planwomen longer life spandeath benefit needs for familyBeauty4 Must Have Documents no tax on withdrawlsemergency fund retirementCommunication Skills do you need life insuranceLTCGay CouplesAmericans don't use all paid vacation timeone annual feedon't do five year car loanMinor Children escrowlife insurance name trust as beneficiaryAccuQuote.comsummer job match income Financial Power of Attorneydon't ignore open enrollmentverify retirement plan with HR or plan sponsorSchool of Social Workthree year car loandental insurance LTCi ASAPholiday spendingbest interest ratesMotherCommencementterm life insurancelow-cost index mutual fundstretch out haircut appointmentshousing marketsecured cardHow To Build Crediteight month living expense same sex marriage band end FloridaBaby BoomersSuze changed my lifeultimate compounding giftpay down student loan debtFHA loan feessmall changes retain separate credit cardsno fee transferclosing feesWarner Bros Television Groupgift grandchild IRA contributionPBS Specialdon't cover cosmetic dentistryhigher insurance deductiblemortgage brokerpush yourself to save more for retirementgift not loan740 credit scoreFinancial Gift Cliffletter to suzebreakdown projected monthly housing costlong-term care premiumsresponsible with moneyno life insurance financially irresponsibleplanlower overall drug costdo not pay allowance for good behaviorCPI-W20% equitylive below your meansautomatic paymentcredit utilization ratehome related tax break bonus best interest of investorprescription tierretirment savingssecure creditmonthly benefit raise deductiblesbad decisionsget health insurancecompare provider pricingwomen live longerpurely financial standpointbest loan deal Save Us Moneyraise insurance deductiblepublic service career student loan repayment contribute household expenses percentage men widowed 75-84car buying mistakesprotect your familyanticipated salaryallowancehome ownershipmortgage interest tax deductionsuccesshealthy retirement blood pressurehealthy aging costly legal College of Veterinary Medicineswitch to roth 401(k)Wall Streetback-to-school budgetBank2016 adjust withholdingexercise reguarlyFinancialSelectQuote.comsocial security never insolventStaffords this year have a fixed 6.8% interest rateARMlong term goalteens and moneyreferrals no splurge 3 bucket approachsavings15-year refinance dealbuying a carbetter loan ratesautomate student loan paymentsSuze OrmanLong Term Care premiumspay more than minimumJose RodriguezFICO at least 720Credit scoresame-sex marriagefiduciary8 Rulesadd teenno interestlife insuranceaffordabilityFinancial Awarenessmax benefit coveredburn outfile taxes quickly

View Blog & News List
People First. Then Money. Then Things.
Connect with me on Facebook Connect with me on YouTube Connect with me on Twitter
© 2017 Suze Orman Media Inc. All rights reserved.
 |  Search  |  Sitemap  |  Privacy  |  Terms
Sign Up For E-mail Offers
Open Panel
Close Panel