Suze Orman TwitterSuze Orman FacebookSuze Orman YouTubeSuze Orman LinkedIn
View Blog & News List

Let’s Not Sell Young Retirement Savers Short

November 03, 2014 at 1:00 AM

Let’s Not Sell Young Retirement Savers Short

A recent paper from the influential Research Affiliates investment management firm (more than $140 billion in assets managed) takes the provocative stance that young adults saving for retirement should not start out with a large portion of their money invested in stocks.

I respectfully disagree.

One key point of the paper is that young adults have a tendency to cash out their 401(k)s when they are laid off. Given that layoffs are most prevalent during a recession-when stock values are falling-the last thing a young person wants is a portfolio that has sharply declined in value right when they need it.

But that just seems to concede that cashing out a 401(k) is a fact of life, and is somehow okay. It is not okay. I don’t think we need to change the portfolio mix for young retirement savers. We need to change the mindset of young workers that their 401(k) is not something to be raided. And that’s a two-step process.

First: We need to show every young adult who wants to take a withdrawal, the opportunity cost of pulling that money out. If we are really being honest that we care about the future of our young adults, and if employers are really serious about wanting to help employees build retirement security, that requires a bit more than lip service.

Educating young adults about the damage of early withdrawals is really low hanging fruit. Why can’t every request for an early withdrawal immediately trigger a message that shows an estimate of what the participant will pocket after paying tax and the 10% early withdrawal penalty and also show an estimate of what the existing balance could grow to by the time that person turns 70, assuming a conservative rate of return of say 4%? And let’s require the participant acknowledge they received this information, and then ask them again if they still want to make the withdrawal. It’s just a nudge. They are still in control. But it forces them to make an informed decision based on facts, not emotion.

Let’s Not Sell Young Retirement Savers Short

Second: We need to do better at encouraging young adults to build an emergency savings account. When you have money set aside for layoffs, or whatever, you will be less inclined to raid your retirement money. The Research Affiliates piece also advocates for this. Where we disagree is that Research Affiliates suggests that the retirement account first start as a safety account: that it be invested conservatively until the balance is equal to six months income.

I think it’s best to keep the two distinct goals in two distinct accounts, and invest each accordingly.

A 401(k) is a horrible rainy day fund: you must pay income tax on 100% of the withdrawn amount and a 10% early withdrawal penalty. I don’t think it’s asking too much of twentysomethings to have them start building an emergency fund by making automatic deposits from their paycheck or checking account into a savings account. I know plenty of twenty somethings doing just that. And if and when they need to tap it, there’s no 10% penalty and the only tax is on interest earned, which these days is nil.

If we really think young adults can’t save for both at once-a point I am not suggesting is true-then at the very least let’s provide good advice: Always save in a 401(k) that offers you a matching contribution, but limit your contribution to what you need to max out on the match. And plan on never touching that 401(k) until retirement. (I also want all 401(k) savers to understand that even if they were to file for bankruptcy, their 401(k) savings will not be touched; all money in a 401(k) is protected in bankruptcy.) With that long-term horizon, let’s do a better job making a case for the long-term benefits of having a heavy allocation to stocks in your younger years.

Then all additional retirement saving should be done in a Roth IRA. All contributions one makes to a Roth IRA can be withdrawn at any time without any tax or penalty; just earnings are subject to both. That’s a better back up emergency fund.

Tag Cloud

Stock InvestmentsPrime Rate Rise 2015traditional vs roth 401(k)iffy income10 year repayment plan purely financial standpointfinancial argumentscommunity collegeRevocable Trust40% toward financial goalno private loanshigh premiumsalternative FICO scoreswitch to spouse coverageletter to suzeemergency fund small changes housing marketCPI-Wmarriage financial responsibility2015 financial roadmapStudent Debt Crisishome buying mistakesalways use all paid time offMoneyEasy Life Insurance point cost offset by savingswomen long term caredon't derail retirement savingsrequire chore in exchange for allowanceNew american Dream wives should be involved in retirementnear historic lowsbalance transfer life insurance name trust as beneficiaryHigh Credit ScoreFRAtax refund fraudVital Documentsone credit cardHeartkid borrow firstnot enough life insurancestay positiveovercome financial fearsHow To Build Creditchildren under 18Commencementdo not pay allowance for good behaviorapproved medical 100% tax-freepay interest while in schoolwould you decline a bonusvalue moneySatisfyinginterest capitalization401(k) Contributionsmortgage interest tax deduction8 month emergency fundRevocable Living Trusthome loan credit score below 740 credit cardAlarm Clock20% down payment avoid feesritual schedulestaycation401KWillrent vs buygift not loanSave Us Moneyget the most out of social security employer funding HSAcontribute household expenses raising mortgage rates teach importance of helping otherslousy investmentadd teenonly refinance if it paysWall StreetSuze Orman Scholarshipeliminate credit card debtmonthly benefit face your financial fearcollege student740 credit scorefocus on new truth calculate dependents annual income needsdon't extend mortgage monthly dental insurance premiumNewtownpaid in fullMass MutualLTC shoppingdebtAuto Savings savings pleasuremental healthreduce interest rateConventional loan PMIretirment savingsHDHP dental insurance save permanent life insurance50 over 50tax ID theftExhibitionprotect loved ones Foreclosuredon't do five year car loangrandchild summer job IRA contributionCollege of Veterinary MedicineMust Have DocumentsPhyllis Shelton expert long-term carefile taxes quicklyspecial saving accountARM Cautionprovider of financial supportfinancial concernhigher insurance deductiblecommunity bankrolloverGay Rightsno splurge Fixed Rate Mortgagedream schoolprotect and provide for minor child focus on needsget credit cardtaxesprotect dependent teens and moneyFinancial Gift Clifflowest cost fund optionNew York LifeAdequate Auto and Home InsuranceSuze approvedloan is giftlong term carelower mortgage interestdoctor no longer in networklower raterefundStaffords this year have a fixed 6.8% interest rateinsurance yearly reviewcar leasingmax employee matchstudent loan repayment estimator8 month safety netoverspend on giftsinterest on student loans3 savings buckets 2016 adjust withholdingitemized deductionsetup automatic savings withdrawno waiting periodget over life insurance phobiaHDHP's are good for youUniversity of IllinoisInfluentialsknow before you owemultiple lenderscreate new truthsecured cardStudent Debtsuccessbig results Swap Older Annuities or Life Insurance holiday spendingBill and Pennypay high rate off firstGiftsPBS Specialproperty taxMarlo ThomasSpendingdon't defer interest paymentspercentage men widowed 75-84HDHP/HSAhigh FICO scoreBankno fee transferuniversal college accessFICO ScoreCivil RightsEmergency SavingsRichretirementFinancial Awarenesscredit unionDeath Benefitdepreciating asset social workbe kind to yourselfraise deductiblesidentity fraudstudent loan repaymentfraudulent returnCD'sFinancial Awareness Video Festivalbad decisions15-year refinance dealFinancial Adviceresponsible with moneyincrease retirement savingsworkaholicthree year car loanbuy homeborrowing plan schedule vacationForbes Top 10no tax on withdrawlsautomate student loan paymentsmortgageFinancial Educatorfour steps to retirement savings Urbana-Champaignbest loan deal financial independence20 to 25 times annual incomepay credit debt ASAPlife insurancebuying car 2016emotional stakesadjust allocations confidentallowancephysical healthdoctors in networkautomatic withdraw to savings Financial Systempresident Obama8 Rulessocial securityno sneaking in feesbe good exampledon't use allowance as bribeWashingtonlow-cost index mutual fund6 month waiting periodcostly insurance mistakelive below your meansautomatic paymentbuy home you can affordnew cardeath benefit 20 to 25 times annual incomePay Off Debt Before Retirementdeath benefit needs for familyno life insurance financially irresponsibleroth irasavingsEric Dodge unexpected expensehome buying budgetzero rate transfer dealsjanuary billsMost Influential Celebrities Listreduce withholdingSuze is my biggest mentorlow mileage discountdon't cover cosmetic dentistryaffordable premiumearn more on savingsbreakdown projected monthly housing costpremiumverify retirement plan with HR or plan sponsorAshley Springerage appropriate choreFinancial Solutions For YouSandy Hook Promisesame-sex marriageat worst still pay 75% benefitis it true? allowance taskhigher monthly paymentteenswomen longer life spanno interestteach your child good money habitsno negativityis it necessary?escrowverify wellness screening and programsmake saving a pleasureplanLoverepay student loansFICO credit score credit card mortgageraise your deductiblecnbc alarm clockfile asapStudent Loanretain separate credit cardscar loanhome budget after tax costmoney vowsno late fee FICO at least 720responsibleavoid burn outbudgetco-sign short term goal incentives for health care wellness screeningemergency fund savingsFundsstudentreal estate mistakescollege graduatepeace of mindhome related tax break bonus 20 year level term Final GoodbyeMoney-Savingdon't spend Gay Couplesno apologyhealthy youhigh credit score discounthigh deductible health care planspeak new goaldon't buy wantsfinancial aidcredit reportCredit Card Interest RateEmployer Matched Contributionget health insurancemortgage brokersame sex marriage band end Floridawomen outlive mentoo expensive schoolcostly legal 19 years cash flow problemvalentines dayHDHP's are not badborrow each year, capitalization is going to pile up required disclosuresidelinedreferrals annual cost of living adjustmentsummer job match income affordabilityreduce monthly paymentcost of capitalization calculatormobile appdangerous retirement planraise insurance deductibleSuze changed my liferising home pricesDurable Power of Attorney for Health CareHolidayHoliday Season!00% tuition paidnon conventional routeclosing fees3 bucket approachincrease emergency savingsgay marriage ban end Florida Roth 401(k)Suze Ormanquick closinghealthy retirement blood pressureCommunication Skills One Wallet At A Timehealthy aging not gender specific ARMcouple financeshealthy retirement weightmax benefit coveredcut monthly cellular billfinancing car shop online guaranteed level term policyreplace permanent life insurance with termpaying for collegefamily save at least $100 monthlycut monthly cable billFinancial Cliffmanage student loansback door Roth IRAmoney-aware child3% debt transferred Combo Insurance Productscommitpay off debtForbesshorter payback periodCNBCunsubsidized Stafford loanLong Term Care premiumsis it kind?Amy LacyetPrime Rate IncreaseFHA loan feesmax employer matched 401(k) contributionone annual feeearn allowanceloan no longer than 36monthsbill paying prioritieskeep a scheduleloved ones dependent on incomeLong Term Care shoppingadvice for college graduatesbad retirement planningno retirement funds for down paymentno private loanMotherFinancialcompare provider pricingAARP Social security calculatorInterestschool Goodbyecan you afford itMoney Marketleave a legacyBankruptcyultimate compounding giftheartachebecome member take actionreal estate marketcontribution stretch out haircut appointmentsUS Tax CodeVeterinary Schoolfinancial fearsdangerous money seasonstandard deduction Fiscal ResponsibilityHSA tax savingspublic service career student loan repayment closing costs 2% of loanLTCi ASAPSchool of Social WorkLong Term Care Insurance ETF'scredit utilization rategraduationloan big picture raising interest rates2016 adjust estimated taxPost-Divorceworst financial mistakecompare monthly expensesanticipated salaryincreased auto insurance premiumpay down student loan debtGraceLifestylebe true to yourselfmaintain standard of livingpositiveSuze Orman spouse Kathy Travismortgage disclosurepowerfulWarner Bros Television Groupchildren's bookUniversity of Florida2017 Taxesburn outjuggle multiple financial goalsgift up to 14,000best interest ratesorigination feesnegotiate points with bank or sellerdebit cardpay more than minimumpay 100% cashincrease retirement contribution rateyours, mine & ourspay down car loanback-to-school budgetChanging LivesSelectQuote.comprescription tierOverspendinghealthy gumshome buying seasonAccuQuote.comlower premiumCredit Card Rate Increasedental discount planstandard ratelow down paymentinsurance mistakestudent loan debtbuy down Federal Reservedo you need life insurancesocial security never insolventoverspend on dining outmarriage inequalityCOLARetirement IncomeIRA contribution gifted moneysocial security not going brokelower interest rateHigh FICO Score = Better Rateclosing disclosureHDHP'sage appropriate goalsloan necessitypercentage of women widowed 75-84financial goal phraserefinancegrandparent IRA contribution long term goalstudent loan repayment plan3 step financial road mapunder 18 financial giftHoliday Shoppingdon't ignore open enrollmentTeachgift grandchild IRA contributionadult childrenInflation Benefitretirement accountsfull retirement agepreexisting condition not covered30 year mortgage ignore 6 month grace period store credit cardshighest possible benefiteight month living expense 20% down paymentaccelerate dental workGiftbetter loan ratesterm life insuranceLegal Guardiandear suzelow credit scorepaid vacation20% equitybetter termsderailed planMortgage Credit Availability Indexconfident of solutionterm insurancelearn good financial choicesoverspend on nights outfederal student loan deferment save moneyinsurance15 year mortgagecharges on credit cardAARPFinancial Power of AttorneyJose Rodriguezhome ownershipSelfishcar buying mistakesinitial tax break meet monthly Cory Bookerswitch to roth 401(k)2015 record year car salesYoung Adult LTCexercise reguarlyFederal Stafford loanBaby Boomersenjoy saving Influential Celebrityspring summer Personal Financebuying a caronly offered while employed Invest for savings growthlong-term care women live longerretirement planhome insuranceMinor Children protect your family10% donate to charitycredit managementtelevision hostFederal PLUS loanCiti Simplicity Card waive home inspection bidsecure creditFree Debt Eliminatortitle insurancelower overall drug costidentity theft4 Must Have Documents push yourself to save more for retirementRetirement Savingsopen enrollment review is it necessaryconsider roth 401(k)long-term care premiumshigh down paymentBeautyFederal Funds RateTelepicturesbetter loan dealshealthy teethSandy Hook Elementary Schoolkids schedule paymentswrite new goalAmericans don't use all paid vacation timecomparison shoppingSuze Orman's Money Warspublic service loan forgiveness programemployer offered life insurancelet them have 50% controlstrained relationshipdon't charge a pennydebt freedental savings planThe Suze Orman Showdon't blow tax refundCredit score


View Blog & News List
People First. Then Money. Then Things.
Connect with me on Facebook Connect with me on YouTube Connect with me on Twitter
© 2017 Suze Orman Media Inc. All rights reserved.
 
 |  Search  |  Sitemap  |  Privacy  |  Terms
Sign Up For E-mail Offers
Open Panel
Close Panel